Tuesday, May 06, 2025

Did Jesus Bookend the Canon in Matthew 23:35 and Luke 11:51?

In Matthew and Luke, Jesus refers to the pair of Abel and Zacharias. 

Matthew 23:35 That upon you may come all the righteous blood shed upon the earth, from the blood of righteous Abel unto the blood of Zacharias son of Barachias, whom ye slew between the temple and the altar.


Luke 11:51 From the blood of Abel unto the blood of Zacharias, which perished between the altar and the temple: verily I say unto you, It shall be required of this generation.


To native English speakers, this may sound like “all from A to Z,” but this is just a coincidence of the English alphabet order - in Greek and Aramaic, Zacharias’ name would not be alphabetically near the end. However, “all … from X to Y,” naturally suggests that X and Y should somehow be book-ending characters.


This mode of speaking is found in a number of places, such as saying “all … from the least … unto the greatest” [FN1] or “all … from one end … to the other end” [FN2].  Sometimes they are more concrete, “all the firstborn … from the firstborn of Pharaoh … unto the firstborn of the maidservant ….” [FN3] or in the form of geographic designations, as in Joshua [FN4]. 


On other hand, single-ended ranges were also used, such as “all the firstborn … from a month old and upward ….,” “from the first day …,” or “from the beginning” – indeed, in Luke’s account of this very event, Jesus says “all the prophets … from the foundation of the world”.


Thus, while it is clear why Abel is selected as the example of the first “righteous blood,” it is less immediately obvious why there should be any end marker to the set.  In other words, why doesn’t Jesus simply say “all the righteous blood that has been shed, from Abel unto now”?  Moreover, why is Abel first and not second in the book-ends?


Considering Luke’s text more closely:


Luke 11:45-51 

Then answered one of the lawyers, and said unto him, Master, thus saying thou reproachest us also. And he said, Woe unto you also, [ye] lawyers! for ye lade men with burdens grievous to be borne, and ye yourselves touch not the burdens with one of your fingers. Woe unto you! for ye build the sepulchres of the prophets, and your fathers killed them. Truly ye bear witness that ye allow the deeds of your fathers: for they indeed killed them, and ye build their sepulchres. Therefore also said the wisdom of God, I will send them prophets and apostles, and [some] of them they shall slay and persecute: that the blood of all the prophets, which was shed from the foundation of the world, may be required of this generation; from the blood of Abel unto the blood of Zacharias, which perished between the altar and the temple: verily I say unto you, It shall be required of this generation.   


Notice that Jesus first gives a single-ended “all the prophets … from the foundation of the world,” but then gives a book-ended “Abel to Zacharias.”  Setting aside alphabetical order, the most obvious and expected reason why Abel would be selected as the starting point of a range is if it is a “from beginning to end” range.  We may then ask ourselves, Why Zacharias?  


From the context, we would expect to find during this period of the “fathers” a prophet named Zacharias who was killed.  However, Jesus provides greater specificity by saying that Zacharias perished between the altar and the temple.  Moreover, considering that this character serves as a book-end, we would expect him to be in the period of “the fathers” and to be the last prophet to be martyred.


This expectation may disappoint us a little.  We find a reference to Zacharias, who was killed in the place Jesus mentioned, but this occurred during the reign of King Joash of Judah (around 800 BC).  On the other hand, there were prophets who lived afterward and who (at least according to Jewish legend) were killed.  Indeed, it is thought that the reference to a person being “sawn asunder” in Hebrews 11 may be an allusion to the death of Isaiah, which occurred a century or more after the death of Zacharias.


Roman Catholics may be even more disappointed, because the deaths of the Maccabean martyrs is righteous blood that came even after Isaiah’s death, and their death is (to Roman Catholics) more than just a pious legend.


Nevertheless, the context of the death of Zacharias is fairly compelling.  Recall the account:


2 Chronicles 24:20-22 

And the Spirit of God came upon Zechariah the son of Jehoiada the priest, which stood above the people, and said unto them, Thus saith God, Why transgress ye the commandments of the LORD, that ye cannot prosper? because ye have forsaken the LORD, he hath also forsaken you. And they conspired against him, and stoned him with stones at the commandment of the king in the court of the house of the LORD. Thus Joash the king remembered not the kindness which Jehoiada his father had done to him, but slew his son. And when he died, he said, The LORD look upon [it], and require [it].


This idea of God “requiring” the death of Zechariah to be punished is quite similar to the concept referenced in Genesis of Abel:


Genesis 4:9-12 

And the LORD said unto Cain, Where [is] Abel thy brother? And he said, I know not: [Am] I my brother's keeper? And he said, What hast thou done? the voice of thy brother's blood crieth unto me from the ground. And now [art] thou cursed from the earth, which hath opened her mouth to receive thy brother's blood from thy hand; When thou tillest the ground, it shall not henceforth yield unto thee her strength; a fugitive and a vagabond shalt thou be in the earth.


Thus, the author of Hebrews personifies Abel’s blood:


Hebrews 11:4 By faith Abel offered unto God a more excellent sacrifice than Cain, by which he obtained witness that he was righteous, God testifying of his gifts: and by it he being dead yet speaketh.

Hebrews 12:24 And to Jesus the mediator of the new covenant, and to the blood of sprinkling, that speaketh better things than [that of] Abel.


The same principle is taken up again in Revelation [FN6].


Still, while both Abel and Zacharias are martyrs, and while the blood of each calls out for God’s vengeance, why select Zacharias?  To put it differently, in what way is Zacharias last to Abel being first?


The most straightforward answer to this is that Zacharias is last within the Hebrew canon.  This is not obvious from the canonical order that we use in the English Bible, where 2 Chronicles is actually fairly early in the list.  On the other hand, 2 Chronicles appears toward the end of the historical books of the Hebrew canon, and the remaining historical books (Ezra and Nehemiah) do not record any martyrdoms.  Interestingly, for a variety of reasons, 2 Chronicles appears as the last book in some Jewish canon lists.[FN7]  


It is not necessary, however, to think that 2 Chronicles was necessarily the last in any official list of Old Testament books at the time of Christ. It could have been that there were official lists with Chronicles last. The Canon List of Baba Bathra (folio 14b) from the Babylonian Talmud, for example, has such a list.[FN8]


However, even if 2 Chronicles was not “officially last,” the Martyrdom of Zechariah is the final martyrdom account within the historical books of the Hebrew canon, although 2 Maccabees (outside the Hebrew canon) contains at least one additional martyrdom account.[FN9]


This is an implicit testimony to the scope of the Old Testament canon.  After all, Jesus is not explicitly saying, “2 Chronicles is the last book of the canon.”  However, the most natural explanation for Jesus’ “from Abel to Zechariah” is that Jesus is identifying the first and last canonical martyrs of the Old Testament.  


Origen is one of the earliest and most influential authors to leave a record of having considered the meaning of Jesus’ statement in a commentary.[FN10] Origen also discusses the question of the meaning of Jesus’ statement in a letter to Africanus [FN11], where he states: 


In the blood of what prophets, can any one tell me? For where do we find anything like this written of Esaias, or Jeremias, or any of the twelve, or Daniel? Then about Zacharias the son of Barachias, who was slain between the temple and the altar, we learn from Jesus only, not knowing it otherwise from any Scripture.


From his commentary, we know that Origen was aware of the Zechariah mentioned in 2 Chronicles 24, because he mentions him as essentially the only Old Testament example of a prophet being killed by the people of Israel in Jerusalem.


Others also quote the section - some without comment on the identity of Zechariah, such as Irenaeus [FN12] or Petilianus the Donatist [FN13] - some with comment, such as Chrysostom [FN14].  The latter writes: “But who is this Zacharias? Some say, the father of John; some, the prophet; some, a priest with two different names, whom the Scripture also calls, the son of Jehoiada.”


Thomas Aquinas, in his Golden Chain [FN15], cites Theophylact as saying “some say was the Zacharias of old time, the son of Jehoiadah the Priest.” He also cites Bede as positively affirming that view and suggesting that the reason for Abel and Zacharias was to affirm people from both classes (laity and priests).  He further cites Gregory of Nyssa as noting that “some say that Zacharias, the father of John” (seemingly alluding back to Origen or Origen’s source, the Protoevangelium of James). He also cites a Greek author (Photius?) who offers a different account of Zacharius (father of John the Baptist) death.


A check of Thomas regarding Theophylact confirms that among other theories, Theophylact mentions the 2 Chronicles 24 Zechariah [FN16].


Romanos the Melodist, Hymn 15, vs. 12, seemed at first glance to tacitly indicate that Zechariah is the 2 Chronicles 24 one (by linking him with Abel) [FN17], but on further reflection this may simply be the Protoevangelium account adopted.


Some will say that it cannot be Zechariah from 2 Chronicles 24 because of the Matthew parallel passage, citing at least two reasons that are only applicable to the Matthew parallel and not to the Luke passage itself.  Thus, it is worth considering the Matthew account in greater detail:


Matthew 23:29-39 

Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! because ye build the tombs of the prophets, and garnish the sepulchres of the righteous, And say, If we had been in the days of our fathers, we would not have been partakers with them in the blood of the prophets. Wherefore ye be witnesses unto yourselves, that ye are the children of them which killed the prophets. Fill ye up then the measure of your fathers. [Ye] serpents, [ye] generation of vipers, how can ye escape the damnation of hell? Wherefore, behold, I send unto you prophets, and wise men, and scribes: and [some] of them ye shall kill and crucify; and [some] of them shall ye scourge in your synagogues, and persecute [them] from city to city: That upon you may come all the righteous blood shed upon the earth, from the blood of righteous Abel unto the blood of Zacharias son of Barachias, whom ye slew between the temple and the altar. Verily I say unto you, All these things shall come upon this generation. O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, [thou] that killest the prophets, and stonest them which are sent unto thee, how often would I have gathered thy children together, even as a hen gathereth her chickens under [her] wings, and ye would not! Behold, your house is left unto you desolate. For I say unto you, Ye shall not see me henceforth, till ye shall say, Blessed [is] he that cometh in the name of the Lord.


The first main reason offered for doubting that Zacharias is the Zechariah of 2 Chronicles 24 is that the text says, “ye slew,” but Zechariah was slain 800 years earlier.  This is solved by noting that Jesus has lumped in the Pharisees with those who killed Zacharias, not simply genetically but because they will also do the same deeds themselves by killing and persecuting the righteous.


Moreover, Jesus makes this point by saying that they “fill up” the “measure of your fathers” and that they “will” do so by subsequent persecutions.  It is then on that basis that they will be held to account for Cain’s murder 4000 years earlier, and Zechariah’s murder 800 years earlier, even though they did not personally commit either one.


A second main reason offered for doubting that Zacharias is the Zechariah of 2 Chronicles 24 is that Jesus refers to him as being “the son of Barachias,” but 2 Chronicles 24 refers to Zechariah as the “son of Jehoiada”[FN17.5].  The minor prophet Zechariah refers to himself as “Zechariah, the son of Berechiah, the son of Iddo the prophet” (Zechariah 1:1&7).  However, this Zechariah lived at the time of Darius during the captivity and return, whereas the 2 Chronicles 24 Zechariah died before the captivity. 


There are multiple ways to resolve this apparent inconsistency.


First, it’s not perfectly clear that Zechariah the minor prophet was literally the son of a man named Berechiah.  While he uses that term of himself, Ezra calls him simply the son of Iddo:


Ezra 5:1 Then the prophets, Haggai the prophet, and Zechariah the son of Iddo, prophesied unto the Jews that [were] in Judah and Jerusalem in the name of the God of Israel, [even] unto them.

Ezra 6:14 And the elders of the Jews builded, and they prospered through the prophesying of Haggai the prophet and Zechariah the son of Iddo. And they builded, and finished [it], according to the commandment of the God of Israel, and according to the commandment of Cyrus, and Darius, and Artaxerxes king of Persia.


If “son of Berechiah” is not a literal patronymic, what else could it be?  It could be a title, like the negative “son of Belial” used in 1 Samuel 2:12, “Now the sons of Eli [were] sons of Belial; they knew not the LORD,” and numerous other places in the Old Testament [FN18].  If so, the meaning of the title would be presumably linked to the meaning of the name, “Blessed [by] Jah” [FN19]. 


Another view is that Jesus used the phrase “son of Barachias” to link the 2 Chronicles 24 Zechariah to the minor prophet Zechariah, through a deliberate name conflation.  It has been argued that this was a thing that was done, and would not imply any error on Jesus’ part, because it was a known homiletic device of the time [FN20].


A further view is that just as Ezra leaves out Berechiah in calling Zechariah the “son of Iddo,” it is likewise possible that Berechiah was the name of one of the male ancestors of the 2 Chronicles 24 Zechariah.  Similar New Testament use of patronymics for other than the direct father include “son of man” (particularly of Jesus), “son of Abraham,” and “son of David.”


More interesting, however, are the uses found in the following examples:


Luke 10:6 And if the son of peace be there, your peace shall rest upon it: if not, it shall turn to you again.


2 Thessalonians 2:3 Let no man deceive you by any means: for that day shall not come, except there come a falling away first, and that man of sin be revealed, the son of perdition;


Acts 4:36 And Joses, who by the apostles was surnamed Barnabas, (which is, being interpreted, The son of consolation,) a Levite, and of the country of Cyprus,


Mark 3:17 And James the son of Zebedee, and John the brother of James; and he surnamed them Boanerges, which is, The sons of thunder:


It would, therefore, be completely in character with Jesus and the apostles to refer to Zechariah the son of Jehoidah with an honorary patronymic, “son of Berechiah,” as way of affirming that Zechariah is “Blessed by Yah.”


Moreover, Jesus goes on to quote:


Psalm 118:26 Blessed [be] he that cometh in the name of the LORD: we have blessed you out of the house of the LORD.


Blessed (in this case) is the Hebrew word בָּרוּךְ (Barak) and LORD is the tetragrammaton YHWH, of which a shortened form is Yah, thereby connecting back with “son of Berechiah.”


Regarding the idea that Zechariah of 2 Chronicles 24 may have had an ancestor named Berechiah, it has been argued that “the only reason you would suggest that is to make the bookends argument work right”[FN21].  


On the other hand, John Chrysostom in his Homily 74 on Matthew said, “But who is this Zacharias? Some say, the father of John; some, the prophet; some, a priest with two different names, whom the Scripture also calls, the son of Jehoiada.”  We have no record of Chrysostom trying to make a bookends argument work, and in context he makes no such reference.


Likewise, Jerome’s Commentary on Matthew, Book 4, at 23:35-36, states [FN22]: 

But we do need to ask who this Zechariah son of Barachiah is. For we read about many Zechariahs. He even removes the possibility of error for us by adding: “whom you killed between the sanctuary and the altar.” … I have read diverse things in diverse sources, and I ought to record the opinions of each of these. … Others want this Zechariah to be the one who was killed between the sanctuary and the altar by Joash king of Judea, as the history of Kings narrates. But one should observe that that Zechariah was not the son of Barachiah, but the son of Jehoiada the priest. This is why the Scripture relates: “Joash did not remember the good deeds of Jehoiada his father, which he had done for him.” Since, then, we should also retain Zechariah and the place of the killing is in agreement, we need to ask why he is called the son of Barachiah, and not of Jehoiada. Barachiah means “blessed of the Lord” in our language, and the justice of the priest Jehoiada is shown in the Hebrew language. In the gospel that the Nazarenes use, in place of “son of Barachiah” we have found it written: “son of Jehoiada.”


Even though Jerome might have been motivated to make a bookends argument, he does not make this connection in his Matthew commentary.


Both Chrysostom and Jerome, however, are motivated by the detail Jesus gives of the location of Zacharias’ homicide.  Thus, they seek to explain the apparent inconsistency: Chrysostom by saying he has two names, and Jerome by suggesting that it is a character appellation (similar to those we saw above, such as Barnabas) or perhaps even a textual variant.


Likewise, as we saw above, even in the case of the minor prophet Zechariah, he is sometimes called “son of Berechiah,” and sometimes “son of Iddo.”  Thus, it is hardly surprising for someone to have two such patronymics, with one being “son of Berechiah.” 


Furthermore, the name “Berechiah” appears multiple times in Chronicles, prior to the birth of Zechariah [FN23] and even within the tribe of Judah. Moreover, we are not given a detailed genealogy as with some other Biblical men.  Thus, it is not at all a stretch to suppose that Jehoiada and Zechariah may have been descendents of Berechiah, such as one of the Berechiahs recorded in Scripture.


Another point that has been raised is the evidence from the Targum


Aramaic Targum to Lamentations 2:20 (Christian M. M. Brady, trans.) [FN24] 

See, O Lord, and observe from heaven against whom you have turned. Thus is it right for the daughters of Israel to eat the fruit of their wombs due to starvation, the lovely boys wrapped in fine linen? The Attribute of Justice replied, and said, “Is it right to kill priest and prophet in the Temple of the LORD, as when you killed Zechariah son of Iddo, the High Priest and faithful prophet in the Temple of the Lord on the Day of Atonement because he admonished you not to do evil before the Lord?”


However, both from the context that Lamentations 2:20 is before death of the minor prophet Zechariah, and from other Targum [FN25], it appears that this may simply be a name conflation in the opposite direction (i.e. calling Zechariah the son of Johoaida the son of Iddo, though he was not).  This does, however, raise the possibility that it was potentially a Jewish custom to link the two (Zechariah of 2 Chronicles 24 and the minor prophet) and to treat them as though they were the same.  


Another option that has been offered, as may be gleaned from the sources discussed above, is the idea that John the Baptist’s father, Zacharias, could be the Zacharias that Jesus had in mind.


On the positive side for this view, the death of Zacharias, father of John the Baptist, could have been much more recent.  However, the primary account that ties Zacharias’ death to the temple is a wholly unreliable tradition from the apocryphal Protoevangelium of James.[FN26] 

Some have argued (see here for example) that Luke must be referring to Zacharias the father of John, because he does not clarify which Zacharias he was mentioning. This seems to be an argument in search of support. While it is true that Zacharias the father of John is mentioned in chapter 1 and then again in chapter 3, it is not clear why Jesus' readers would need clarification if a different person was intended. After all, there is no hint in Luke's gospel that Zacharias the father of the forerunner met any unnatural end. Moreover, the clarification of which Zacharias is provided by Jesus' own explanation, "which perished between the altar and the temple," of which there was exactly one such Zacharias in the canonical books.

Likewise, from the same video, some have argued that it must be Zacharias because it must be someone that had been personally killed by those present. Of course, Luke's version of Jesus' statement does not include this identification of the lawyers as the killers. Moreover, it is Jesus' point -- not to say that the lawyers were personally killers, but that they endorsed the killing:

Luke 11:47-48 Woe unto you! for ye build the sepulchres of the prophets, and your fathers killed them. 48 Truly ye bear witness that ye allow the deeds of your fathers: for they indeed killed them, and ye build their sepulchres.

In context, then, the deeds of which Jesus is complaining are from the time of "the fathers" not the current time.

A final objection that is sometimes raised is that this theory is new, having only arisen in the 1700s and possibly as a response to the canon order found in printed Hebrew Old Testaments. While this may be correct, it's partly because there was not a lot of thought expended on the question: why did Jesus select these two specific examples? So, it's not as though a traditional interpretation was overthrown, but rather an overlooked aspect of the text was brought out, one that was consistent with (not contradictory to) the previous traditional interpretations.


FN1: 

[Jer 31:34 KJV] 34 And they shall teach no more every man his neighbour, and every man his brother, saying, Know the LORD: for they shall all know me, from the least of them unto the greatest of them, saith the LORD: for I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more.

[Jer 42:1, 8 KJV] 1 Then all the captains of the forces, and Johanan the son of Kareah, and Jezaniah the son of Hoshaiah, and all the people from the least even unto the greatest, came near, ... 8 Then called he Johanan the son of Kareah, and all the captains of the forces which [were] with him, and all the people from the least even to the greatest,

[Jer 44:12 KJV] 12 And I will take the remnant of Judah, that have set their faces to go into the land of Egypt to sojourn there, and they shall all be consumed, [and] fall in the land of Egypt; they shall [even] be consumed by the sword [and] by the famine: they shall die, from the least even unto the greatest, by the sword and by the famine: and they shall be an execration, [and] an astonishment, and a curse, and a reproach.

[Act 8:10 KJV] 10 To whom they all gave heed, from the least to the greatest, saying, This man is the great power of God.

[Heb 8:11 KJV] 11 And they shall not teach every man his neighbour, and every man his brother, saying, Know the Lord: for all shall know me, from the least to the greatest.


FN2:

[Jer 12:12 KJV] 12 The spoilers are come upon all high places through the wilderness: for the sword of the LORD shall devour from the [one] end of the land even to the [other] end of the land: no flesh shall have peace.

[Deu 28:64 KJV] 64 And the LORD shall scatter thee among all people, from the one end of the earth even unto the other; and there thou shalt serve other gods, which neither thou nor thy fathers have known, [even] wood and stone.


FN3: 

[Exo 11:5 KJV] 5 And all the firstborn in the land of Egypt shall die, from the firstborn of Pharaoh that sitteth upon his throne, even unto the firstborn of the maidservant that [is] behind the mill; and all the firstborn of beasts.


FN4:

[Jos 12:1 KJV] 1 Now these [are] the kings of the land, which the children of Israel smote, and possessed their land on the other side Jordan toward the rising of the sun, from the river Arnon unto mount Hermon, and all the plain on the east:

[Jos 13:4-5, 9 KJV] 4 From the south, all the land of the Canaanites, and Mearah that [is] beside the Sidonians, unto Aphek, to the borders of the Amorites: 5 And the land of the Giblites, and all Lebanon, toward the sunrising, from Baalgad under mount Hermon unto the entering into Hamath. ... 9 From Aroer, that [is] upon the bank of the river Arnon, and the city that [is] in the midst of the river, and all the plain of Medeba unto Dibon;

[Jos 15:46 KJV] 46 From Ekron even unto the sea, all that [lay] near Ashdod, with their villages:


FN5: 

[Num 3:40 KJV] 40 And the LORD said unto Moses, Number all the firstborn of the males of the children of Israel from a month old and upward, and take the number of their names.

[Act 20:18 KJV] 18 And when they were come to him, he said unto them, Ye know, from the first day that I came into Asia, after what manner I have been with you at all seasons,

[Act 15:18 KJV] 18 Known unto God are all his works from the beginning of the world.

[Luk 11:50 KJV] 50 That the blood of all the prophets, which was shed from the foundation of the world, may be required of this generation;


FN6:

The martyrs in Revelation make a similar demand for justice:

Revelation 6:9-11 

And when he had opened the fifth seal, I saw under the altar the souls of them that were slain for the word of God, and for the testimony which they held: And they cried with a loud voice, saying, How long, O Lord, holy and true, dost thou not judge and avenge our blood on them that dwell on the earth? And white robes were given unto every one of them; and it was said unto them, that they should rest yet for a little season, until their fellowservants also and their brethren, that should be killed as they [were], should be fulfilled.

This demand is met in Revelation 15-16:

Revelation 15:1-16:7 KJV] And I saw another sign in heaven, great and marvellous, seven angels having the seven last plagues; for in them is filled up the wrath of God. And I saw as it were a sea of glass mingled with fire: and them that had gotten the victory over the beast, and over his image, and over his mark, [and] over the number of his name, stand on the sea of glass, having the harps of God. And they sing the song of Moses the servant of God, and the song of the Lamb, saying, Great and marvellous [are] thy works, Lord God Almighty; just and true [are] thy ways, thou King of Nations. Who shall not fear thee, O Lord, and glorify thy name? for [thou] only [art] holy: for all nations shall come and worship before thee; for thy judgments are made manifest. And after that I looked, and, behold, the temple of the tabernacle of the testimony in heaven was opened: And the seven angels came out of the temple, having the seven plagues, clothed in pure and white linen, and having their breasts girded with golden girdles. And one of the four beasts gave unto the seven angels seven golden vials full of the wrath of God, who liveth for ever and ever. And the temple was filled with smoke from the glory of God, and from his power; and no man was able to enter into the temple, till the seven plagues of the seven angels were fulfilled. And I heard a great voice out of the temple saying to the seven angels, Go your ways, and pour out the vials of the wrath of God upon the earth. … And the second angel poured out his vial upon the sea; and it became as the blood of a dead [man]: and every living soul died in the sea. And the third angel poured out his vial upon the rivers and fountains of waters; and they became blood. And I heard the angel of the waters say, Thou art righteous, O Lord, which art, and wast, O Holy One! because thou hast judged thus. For they have shed the blood of saints and prophets, and thou hast given them blood to drink; for they are worthy. And I heard another out of the altar say, Even so, Lord God Almighty, true and righteous [are] thy judgments.


I’ve corrected “and shalt be” to “O Holy One!” in Revelation 16:5 and similarly “Saints” to “Nations” in Revelation 15:3.


FN7:

For example, the Jewish encyclopedia states: “The Jewish canon comprises twenty-four books, the five of the Pentateuch, eight books of the Prophets (Joshua, Judges, Samuel, Kings, Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, the Minor Prophets), and eleven Hagiographa (Psalms, Proverbs, Job, Song of Solomon, Ruth, Lamentations, Ecclesiastes, Esther,Daniel, Ezra, and Chronicles).”  https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/3259-bible-canon 


FN8:

https://sanctushieronymus.blogspot.com/2012/02/canon-list-of-baba-bathra-14b.html 

 

FN9:

2 Maccabees 7 https://bible.usccb.org/bible/2maccabees/7 


Origen’s commentary on Luke 11 seems to have been lost, but his commentary on Matthew remains, at least in a Latin translation.  Origen The Commentary Of Origen On The Gospel Of St Matthew, vol. 1, p. 29: “There is an ancient Latin translation of the latter portion of the Commentary on Matthew, done perhaps in the sixth century by an unknown translator.” 


https://archive.org/details/origen-the-commentary-of-origen-on-the-gospel-of-st-matthew-2/Origen%20-%20The%20Commentary%20of%20Origen%20on%20the%20Gospel%20of%20St%20Matthew%201/page/29/mode/2up 


From The Series Commentariorum (On Matthew 22:34-27:66), volume 2 of Origen The Commentary Of Origen On The Gospel Of St Matthew. 


(pp. 575-76)

Section 25:

But those who were reproached by Christ could not have killed “Zachariah son of Barachiah, one of the twelve prophets, whose writings we have in hand.[FN] But he means ‘Zachariah’ father of John, of whom we cannot show by the canonical Scriptures that he was either the son of ‘Barachiah’ or that the scribes and Pharisees killed him ‘between the temple and the altar. But a certain tradition has come to us that there is some place in the temple where virgins were permitted to stop and pray to God, but women who had experienced the bed of a man were not permitted to stop in that place. And after Mary had given birth to the Saviour, she entered and stopped to worship in that place of the virgins, and when those who knew that she had given birth to a son forbid her, Zachariah stopped and said to those forbidding her that she was worthy of the place of the virgins since she was still a virgin. Therefore, as ‘Zachariah’ was very clearly acting against the law and permitting a wife to stand in the place of the virgins, the men of that generation killed him “between the temple and the altar. Moreover, let us demand that those who do not accept a tradition of this kind provide an explanation of how Jesus reproached them because of Zachariah, not as the sons of those who killed “Zachariah immediately after the prophets, but as those who themselves killed Zachariah “between the temple and the altar’ If, therefore, the word Christ addressed to the Pharisees and scribes who were present at that time is true, ‘whom you killed between the temple and the altar} it is not possible to understand that ‘Zachariah’ who is one of the twelve prophets. Nor furthermore is it strange if it turns out that each ‘Zachariah and their fathers have the same name.


[FN The following is a parallel to this discussion in an anonymous Greek fragment in the Scholia Commentary of Peter of Laodicea: ‘For those now reproached by the Saviour could not have killed Zachariah the son of Barachiah who was numbered among the twelve prophets, but it is likely [as Joseppus says] that the Zachariah now mentioned was the father of John, of whom we are able to show from the Scriptures neither that he was the son of Barachiah nor that the scribes and Pharisees killed him “between the temple and the altar”. But some such tradition has reached us that at that time there was some place in the temple where virgins were permitted to enter and worship God, and those who had already experienced intercourse with a man were not permitted in that place. Mary, therefore, after giving birth to [our] Saviour went to worship and stood in the place of the virgins. And when those who knew she had given birth were forbidding her, Zachariah said to those forbidding her that she was worthy of the place of the virgins since she was still a virgin. Since, therefore, he was clearly contradicting the law and permitting a wife to be in the place of the virgins, those of that generation killed him “between the temple and the altar”. They are reproached by the Saviour, therefore, not as the sons of those who killed the prophets and Zachariah after the prophets, but as themselves having killed him. And it is not strange if it turns out that Zachariah, the father of John, has the same name as the one among the twelve prophets. So too the father of the father’.]


(p. 580)

Section 27

In this way, they also pour out the blood ‘of Zachariah, which means ‘Remembrance of God: For everyone who is eager to destroy the remembrance of God in those whom they cause to stumble is seen to pour out the blood ‘of Zachariah the son of Barachiah, whose name also means ‘the praising of God. For by the praising of God we are mindful of God. … The impious kill the remembrance of God ‘between the temple and the altar’ when the lewd corrupt the ‘temple’ of God, and its altar is polluted by the carelessness of disgraceful prayers, when the prayer of someone becomes his sin, as also it is said of the prayer of Judah, ‘Let his prayer be counted as his sin.


(pp. 580-81)

Section 28

It is worth investigating why, when the Saviour was speaking before hearers who included the scribes and Pharisees who boasted that they knew precisely what things belonged to the law and the prophets,'*" he said ‘Jerusalem’ had killed ‘the prophets’ and stoned ‘those sent’ to it when not much history of this kind is prophesied in the old Scriptures that are read in their synagogues. We read that Jeremiah was thrown into a cistern of mud;'*? he was not, however, killed in Jerusalem. But neither do we read that Isaiah, or Ezekiel, or any of the prophets suffered any such thing, so far as my memory recalls. But examining the second book of Chronicles, where many things are written about the illustrious prophets, I discovered that Asa, angered at the prophet Hanani who censured him, put him in jail, but he did nothing more against him.'** But also Ahab ordered Micaiah, who prophesied against him, to be imprisoned and to eat the bread of tribulation, but he did not kill him.'** But we read of one who was stoned, ‘Zechariah, son of the priest Jehoiada, when he censured the people.'** We do not, therefore, find more prophets killed in Jerusalem, or stoned (other than I mentioned) who had been sent to Jerusalem.

For this reason, we must see if perhaps we must explain the word of Christ from books that are more secret which are current among the Jews, and not only the word of Christ, but also that of his disciples, Stephen the first martyr, and Paul the apostle. For Stephen spoke as follows: ‘O stiff-necked and uncircumcised in heart and ears, you always resist the Holy Spirit, just as your fathers did, so also you. For which of the prophets did your fathers not persecute? And they killed those who announced the coming of the Just One, of whom you are now his betrayers and murderers’; and after this ‘they cast him out of the city and they stoned Stephen, calling out and saying.’** And Paul says the following about the killing of the prophets in the first letter to the Thessalonians: ‘For you have become imitators of the churches of God that are in Judaea in Christ Jesus, because you yourselves have suffered the same things from your countrymen as they too from the Jews, who killed the Lord Jesus and the prophets and have persecuted us, and are not pleasing to God?**” And to the Hebrews as follows: “They were stoned, they were sawn in pieces, they were tempted, killed by the sword, they wandered in sheepskins, in goatskins, being in need, restricted, afflicted with pains, of whom the world was not worthy, wandering in deserts, in mountains, in caves, and in pits of the earth.'** It is related, therefore, in unclear Scriptures that Isaiah was sawn in pieces and Zechariah and Ezekiel killed. And I think that Elijah, who wandered in the desert and in mountains, went around in sheepskins and goatskins. But assume that someone denies that the Epistle to the Hebrews is by Paul, and also denies the secret book of Isaiah; but what will he do with the words cited of Stephen, or Paul to the Thessalonians about prophets who were killed, or of our Lord himself? Or how will he deny that which Paul mentioned to Timothy, saying, ‘Just as Jannes and Jambres resisted Moses, so also those resist the truth’?**? And if he should also look at what is related in the first letter to the Corinthians, ‘What eye has not seen, or ear heard, how will anyone be able to deny all these things?**°

We have said all these things discussing the remark, not unaware that there are many fabrications of secrets by the impious who speak ‘iniquity against the height:?*! The followers of Hypythianus’*? use certain fabrications, and those who are followers of Basilides use others. We must, therefore, give careful consideration so that we not accept all secret books that are passed off in the name of saints, because of the Jews who, to confirm false doctrines, have perhaps fabricated certain works to destroy the truth of our Scriptures; we must also be careful not to deny all works that relate to the explanation of our Scriptures. It is the mark of a great person to hear and do what is said: ‘Prove all things; hold on to what is good?!5? Nevertheless, because of those who are not able, as money-changers,’** to discern whether words are true or false, and are not able themselves to guard carefully that they hold the true in themselves, ‘let them abstain from every evil appearance.’** No one ought to use books outside the canonical Scriptures to confirm doctrines.

Nevertheless, if someone accepts the “To the Hebrews’ as an epistle of Paul, he will say that we ought not use the plural at all in many references. For not many were sawn in pieces, but Isaiah alone; nor were many stoned but only Zechariah, son of Jehoiada; and only Zechariah son of Barachiah was killed by the sword; so also Elijah went about in sheepskins and goatskins; and other similar examples.’*° But further, let us investigate what is written in Luke when the Lord says, ‘Because it is not possible that a prophet perish outside of Jerusalem:’*” If, therefore, ‘it is not possible that a prophet perish outside of Jerusalem; that is, be killed, you will ask if no one was a prophet after the destruction of Jerusalem, lest perhaps a prophet killed ‘outside Jerusalem’ prove Christ’s word false. And if the Scriptures, on account of Agabus and the daughters of Philip the evangelist (not because of the false prophets of Phrygia'**) compel us, let us ask whether every just person is perhaps in Jerusalem and is not ‘outside Jerusalem, because ‘it is not possible’ for one who is outside Jerusalem to be afflicted with sufferings for the sake of the Word.


https://archive.org/details/origen-the-commentary-of-origen-on-the-gospel-of-st-matthew-2/Origen%20-%20The%20Commentary%20of%20Origen%20on%20the%20Gospel%20of%20St%20Matthew%202/page/580/mode/2up


FN11:

https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0414.htm 


FN12:

https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0103514.htm 

In like manner, too, did the Lord say to those who should afterwards shed His blood, All righteous blood shall be required which is shed upon the earth, from the blood of righteous Abel to the blood of Zacharias the son of Barachias, whom you slew between the temple and the altar. Verily I say unto you, All these things shall come upon this generation. He thus points out the recapitulation that should take place in his own person of the effusion of blood from the beginning, of all the righteous men and of the prophets, and that by means of Himself there should be a requisition of their blood. Now this [blood] could not be required unless it also had the capability of being saved; nor would the Lord have summed up these things in Himself, unless He had Himself been made flesh and blood after the way of the original formation [of man], saving in his own person at the end that which had in the beginning perished in Adam.


FN13:

https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/14092.htm 

Petilianus said: "In the third place, also, He calls the madness of persecutors in like manner by this name, ‘You generation of vipers, how can you escape the damnation of hell? Wherefore, behold, I send unto you prophets, and wise men, and scribes; and some of them you shall kill and crucify; and some of them shall you scourge in your synagogues, and persecute them from city to city: that upon you may come all the righteous blood shed upon the earth, from the blood of righteous Abel unto the blood of Zacharias, son of Barachias, whom you slew between the temple and the altar.' Matthew 23:33-35 Are they then really the sons of vipers according to the flesh, and not rather serpents in mind, and three-tongued malice, and deadliness of touch, and burning with the spirit of poison? They have truly become vipers, who by their bites have vomited forth death against the innocent people."


FN14:


https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/200174.htm



FN15:


Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain, https://isidore.co/aquinas/english/CALuke.htm#11 


THEOPHYL. But our Lord shows that the Jews have inherited the malice of Cain, since he adds, From the blood of Abel, to the blood of Zacharias, &c. Abel, inasmuch as he was slain by Cain; but Zacharias, whom they slew between the temple and the altar, some say was the Zacharias of old time, the son of Jehoiadah the Priest. BEDE; Why He begins from the blood of Abel, who was the first martyr, we need not wonder; but why, to the blood, of Zacharias, is a question, since many were slain after him even up to our Lord’s birth, and soon after His birth the Innocents, unless perhaps it was because Abel was a shepherd, Zacharias a Priest. And the one was killed in the field, the other in the court of the temple, martyrs of each class, that is, under their names are shadowed both laymen, and those engaged in the office of the altar.


GREG NYSS. But some say that Zacharias, the father of John, by the spirit of prophecy forecasting the mystery of the immaculate virginity of the mother of God, in no wise separated her from the part of the temple set apart for virgins, wishing to show that it was in the power of the Creator of all things to manifest a new birth, while he did not deprive the mother of the glory of her virginity. Now this part was between the altar and the temple, in which was placed the brazen altar, where for this reason they slew him. It is said also, that when they heard the King of the world was about to come, form fear of subjection they designedly attacked him who bore witness to His coming, and slew the priest in the temple.


GREEK EX. But others give another reason for the destruction of Zacharias. For at the murder of the children the blessed John was to be slain with the rest of the same age, but Elizabeth, snatching up her son from the midst of the slaughter, sought the desert. And so when Herod’s soldiers could not find Elisabeth and the child, they turn their wrath against Zacharias, killing him as he was ministering in the temple.


FN16:


On the Matthew passage, Theophylact writes:


But of which Zechariah is he here making mention? Some say of the one numbered among the twelve prophets; others, of the father of the Forerunner. For a tradition has been handed down to us that there was a certain place in the temple where the virgins stood. Now Zechariah, being a high priest, after the birth of Christ placed the Mother of God in the place of the virgins. The Jews, becoming angry at this, killed him, as having assigned a woman who had given birth to a place among virgins. And it is not surprising if even the father of the Forerunner had a father named Barachiah, just as the one among the twelve prophets is called the son of Barachiah; for it is likely that just as their names coincided, so also did those of their fathers.


Ποίου δὲ Ζαχαρίου ἐνταῦθα μέμνηται; Οἱ μὲν τοῦ ἐν τοῖς δώδεκα προφήταις φασὶ συναριθμουμένου· οἱ δέ, τοῦ πατρὸς τοῦ Προδρόμου· λόγος γὰρ ἔχει παραδοθεὶς ἡμῖν, ὅτι τόπος τις ἦν ἐν τῷ ναῷ, ἐν ᾧ ἵσταντο αἱ παρθένοι. Ὁ τοίνυν Ζαχαρίας ἀρχιερεὺς ὤν, καὶ μετὰ τὸ τεκεῖν τὸν Χριστὸν τὴν Θεοτόκον ἔστησεν ἐν τῷ τόπῳ τῶν παρθένων· ἀγανακτήσαντες δὲ ἐπὶ τούτῳ οἱ Ἰουδαῖοι, ἀπέκτειναν αὐτόν, ὡς μετὰ τῶν παρθένων τάξαντα γυναῖκα γεννήσασαν· οὐδὲν δὲ θαυμαστόν, εἰ καὶ ὁ πατὴρ τοῦ Προδρόμου εἶχε πατέρα Βαραχίαν ὀνόματι, ὥσπερ καὶ ὁ ἐν τοῖς δώδεκα προφήταις Βαραχίου λέγεται υἱός· εἰκὸς γὰρ ὥσπερ τὰ τούτων ὀνόματα συνέδραμον, οὕτω καὶ τὰ τῶν πατέρων αὐτῶν.


On the Luke passage, Theophylact writes:


Who, then, was this Zechariah whom they killed between the temple and the altar? Some say it was the ancient Zechariah, the son of Jehoiada, whom they stoned, as can be learned from the Book of Kings. But others say it was the father of the Forerunner (John the Baptist), because he placed the Theotokos among the virgins after she had given birth to Christ, positioning her in the place where they stood; this place was between the temple and the outer bronze altar. Therefore, they killed him. For since certain people expected Christ to be their king, yet did not wish to be ruled, they murdered this holy man, because he affirmed that a virgin had given birth, and that Christ, the one who would become their king—something they rejected—had been born; for they wished to remain kingless.


Τίς δὲ ἦν ἄρα Ζαχαρίας, ὃν ἐφόνευσαν μεταξὺ τοῦ ναοῦ καὶ τοῦ θυσιαστηρίου; Οἱ μὲν λέγουσι τὸν ἀρχαῖον Ζαχαρίαν τὸν τοῦ Ἰωάδε, καὶ ὃν ἐλιθοβόλησαν, ὡς ἔστι μαθεῖν ἐκ τῆς βίβλου τῶν Βασιλειῶν· οἱ δὲ τὸν πατέρα τοῦ Προδρόμου, τοῦτον γὰρ τάξαντα τὴν Θεοτόκον μετὰ τῶν παρθένων μετὰ τὸ τεκεῖν τὸν Χριστόν, καὶ στήσαντα ταύτην ἐν τῷ τόπῳ ἐν ᾧ ἐκεῖναι ἵσταντο· ὁ δὲ τόπος ἦν μεταξὺ τοῦ ναοῦ καὶ τοῦ θυσιαστηρίου τοῦ ἔξω τοῦ χαλκοῦ. Διὰ τοῦτο τοίνυν ἐφόνευσαν αὐτόν. Ἐπεὶ γὰρ προσεδόκων τινὲς τὸν Χριστὸν βασιλέα αὑτῶν ἐσόμενον, οὐκ ἤθελον δὲ βασιλευθῆναι, τούτου ἕνεκα ἐφόνευσαν τὸν ἅγιον, ὡς βεβαιοῦντα ὅτι παρθένος ἔτεκεν, καὶ ὁ Χριστὸς ἐγεννήθη ὁ μέλλων αὐτῶν βασιλεύειν, ὅπερ ἀπεστρέφοντο· ἀβασίλευτοι γὰρ ἤθελον εἶναι.



FN17:


Romanos the Melodist, Hymn 15, vs. 12:


As the lawless ones sprinkle innocent blood

of the harmless infants, it was necessary to remember

Abel, who offered a sacrifice to God pure and undefiled,

and to comfort him; for he too was slain.

And again, it was necessary to look upon Zechariah,

how he there will bring an accusation before God

against those who killed him. For always the Jews

and their rulers are insolent and lawless,

murderers and senseless and transgressors of the Law;

they rejected Moses, and once even sawed Isaiah in half;

and now they slaughter Rachel’s infants; therefore she also laments

<because their power is quickly destroyed.>


Ῥαινόντων τῶν ἀνόμων    ἀθῷον αἷμα

    τῶν ἀκάκων νηπίων,    ἔδει μνησθῆναι

    Ἄβελ τοῦ προσάξαντος    τὴν θυσίαν τῷ Θεῷ    καθαρὰν καὶ ἀμόλυντον,

  καὶ παραμυθηθῆναι·    κἀκεῖνος γὰρ ἐκτάνθη.

    Καὶ πάλιν Ζαχαρίαν    ἐχρῆν κατιδεῖν,    

ὡς τῷ Θεῷ ἐκεῖ    κατηγορίαν προσάξει

    κατὰ τῶν τοῦτον    ἀποκτεινάντων·    ἀεὶ γάρ εἰσιν    οἱ Ἰουδαῖοι

καὶ οἱ τούτων ἀνάσσοντες    ὑβρισταὶ καὶ παράνομοι,

    φονευταὶ καὶ ἀσυνετοὶ    καὶ νόμον παραβαίνοντες·

  τὸν Μωϋσῆν ἠθέτησαν,    Ἠσαΐαν δὲ αὐτοὶ    μέσον ἔπρισάν ποτε·   

    καὶ τὰ βρέφη τῆς Ῥαχὴλ    κατασφάττουσι νῦν·    διὰ τοῦτο καὶ θρηνοῦν

    <ὅτι τὸ κράτος αὐτοῦ    καθαιρεῖται ταχύ.>


Abel is the first martyr in the Hebrew canon and Zacharias is the final martyr in the Hebrew canon.  


FN17.5:

Interestingly, it is possible that the “son of Jehoiada” should be taken in some honorary way.  After all, the location of killing of Zechariah is reminiscent of an account from the life of Jehoiada:


2 Chronicles 23:12-15 

Now when Athaliah heard the noise of the people running and praising the king, she came to the people into the house of the LORD: And she looked, and, behold, the king stood at his pillar at the entering in, and the princes and the trumpets by the king: and all the people of the land rejoiced, and sounded with trumpets, also the singers with instruments of musick, and such as taught to sing praise. Then Athaliah rent her clothes, and said, Treason, Treason. Then Jehoiada the priest brought out the captains of hundreds that were set over the host, and said unto them, Have her forth of the ranges: and whoso followeth her, let him be slain with the sword. For the priest said, Slay her not in the house of the LORD. So they laid hands on her; and when she was come to the entering of the horse gate by the king's house, they slew her there.


However, the wording of account of the death of Zechariah is most naturally taken as referring to his natural son, particularly because of the use of “Jehoiada his father”:


2 Chronicles 24:15-22 

But Jehoiada waxed old, and was full of days when he died; an hundred and thirty years old [was he] when he died. And they buried him in the city of David among the kings, because he had done good in Israel, both toward God, and toward his house. Now after the death of Jehoiada came the princes of Judah, and made obeisance to the king. Then the king hearkened unto them. And they left the house of the LORD God of their fathers, and served groves and idols: and wrath came upon Judah and Jerusalem for this their trespass. Yet he sent prophets to them, to bring them again unto the LORD; and they testified against them: but they would not give ear. And the Spirit of God came upon Zechariah the son of Jehoiada the priest, which stood above the people, and said unto them, Thus saith God, Why transgress ye the commandments of the LORD, that ye cannot prosper? because ye have forsaken the LORD, he hath also forsaken you. And they conspired against him, and stoned him with stones at the commandment of the king in the court of the house of the LORD. Thus Joash the king remembered not the kindness which Jehoiada his father had done to him, but slew his son. And when he died, he said, The LORD look upon [it], and require [it].



FN18:


[Deu 13:13 KJV] 13 [Certain] men, the children of Belial, are gone out from among you, and have withdrawn the inhabitants of their city, saying, Let us go and serve other gods, which ye have not known;

[Jdg 19:22 KJV] 22 [Now] as they were making their hearts merry, behold, the men of the city, certain sons of Belial, beset the house round about, [and] beat at the door, and spake to the master of the house, the old man, saying, Bring forth the man that came into thine house, that we may know him.

[Jdg 20:13 KJV] 13 Now therefore deliver [us] the men, the children of Belial, which [are] in Gibeah, that we may put them to death, and put away evil from Israel. But the children of Benjamin would not hearken to the voice of their brethren the children of Israel:

[1Sa 1:16 KJV] 16 Count not thine handmaid for a daughter of Belial: for out of the abundance of my complaint and grief have I spoken hitherto.

[1Sa 2:12 KJV] 12 Now the sons of Eli [were] sons of Belial; they knew not the LORD.

[1Sa 10:27 KJV] 27 But the children of Belial said, How shall this man save us? And they despised him, and brought him no presents. But he held his peace.

[1Sa 25:17, 25 KJV] 17 Now therefore know and consider what thou wilt do; for evil is determined against our master, and against all his household: for he [is such] a son of Belial, that [a man] cannot speak to him. ... 25 Let not my lord, I pray thee, regard this man of Belial, [even] Nabal: for as his name [is], so [is] he; Nabal [is] his name, and folly [is] with him: but I thine handmaid saw not the young men of my lord, whom thou didst send.

[1Sa 30:22 KJV] 22 Then answered all the wicked men and [men] of Belial, of those that went with David, and said, Because they went not with us, we will not give them [ought] of the spoil that we have recovered, save to every man his wife and his children, that they may lead [them] away, and depart.

[2Sa 16:7 KJV] 7 And thus said Shimei when he cursed, Come out, come out, thou bloody man, and thou man of Belial:

[2Sa 20:1 KJV] 1 And there happened to be there a man of Belial, whose name [was] Sheba, the son of Bichri, a Benjamite: and he blew a trumpet, and said, We have no part in David, neither have we inheritance in the son of Jesse: every man to his tents, O Israel.

[2Sa 23:6 KJV] 6 But [the sons] of Belial [shall be] all of them as thorns thrust away, because they cannot be taken with hands:

[1Ki 21:10, 13 KJV] 10 And set two men, sons of Belial, before him, to bear witness against him, saying, Thou didst blaspheme God and the king. And [then] carry him out, and stone him, that he may die. ... 13 And there came in two men, children of Belial, and sat before him: and the men of Belial witnessed against him, [even] against Naboth, in the presence of the people, saying, Naboth did blaspheme God and the king. Then they carried him forth out of the city, and stoned him with stones, that he died.

[2Ch 13:7 KJV] 7 And there are gathered unto him vain men, the children of Belial, and have strengthened themselves against Rehoboam the son of Solomon, when Rehoboam was young and tenderhearted, and could not withstand them.


FN19:


Genesius’ Hebrew-Chaldee Lexicon:

https://www.blueletterbible.org/lexicon/h1296/kjv/wlc/0-1/



FN20:


[Incomplete]  p. 219 of Roger T. Beckwith, “The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and its background in Early Judaism.”


FN21:

“Is the Canonical Bookends Argument Solid? (Lk 11:49-51; Mt 23:34-36),” Apocrypha Apocalypse channel, Gary Michuta, 10:12 into the video: https://youtu.be/vM85w_SF2gk?t=612 


FN22:

https://turretinfan.blogspot.com/2025/04/john-chrysostom-and-jerome-on-zechariah.html 


FN23:

Among the list of Solomon’s sons:

[1Ch 3:20 KJV] 20 And Hashubah, and Ohel, and Berechiah, and Hasadiah, Jushabhesed, five.

As a Levite:

[1Ch 9:16 KJV] 16 And Obadiah the son of Shemaiah, the son of Galal, the son of Jeduthun, and Berechiah the son of Asa, the son of Elkanah, that dwelt in the villages of the Netophathites.

As Levites (specifically at the time of David):

[1Ch 15:17, 23 KJV] 17 So the Levites appointed Heman the son of Joel; and of his brethren, Asaph the son of Berechiah; and of the sons of Merari their brethren, Ethan the son of Kushaiah; ... 23 And Berechiah and Elkanah [were] doorkeepers for the ark.


FN24: 

Aramaic Targum to Lamentations 2:20 (Christian M. M. Brady, trans.) [FN24] https://www.sefaria.org/Aramaic_Targum_to_Lamentations.2?lang=bi 



FN25:


Multiple Targumim describe the martyrdom of Zechariah:


Gittin 57b:3; The William Davidson Talmud (Koren - Steinsaltz) https://www.sefaria.org/Gittin.57b.3?lang=bi 

Nebuzaradan said to them: If you tell me whose blood this is, it will be well for you. But if not, I will comb your flesh with iron combs. They said to him: What shall we say to you? He was a prophet among us, who used to rebuke us about heavenly matters, and we rose up against him, and killed him (II Chronicles 24:20–22), and for many years now his blood has not settled.


Jerusalem Talmud Taanit 4:5:17; Heinrich W. Guggenheimer, 1999-2015 https://www.sefaria.org/Jerusalem_Talmud_Taanit.4.5.17?lang=bi 

Rebbi Joḥanan said, 80’000 young priests were slaughtered for the blood of Zachariah. Rebbi Yudan asked Rebbi Aḥa, where did they kill Zachariah? In the women’s courtyard or in Israel’s courtyard? He said to him, neither in Israel’s courtyard nor in the women’s courtyard but in the priests’ courtyard. They treated his blood neither as ram’s blood nor as gazelle’s blood. There is written, he shall pour out its blood and cover it with dust. But here, for its blood was in its midst, on a bare rock he put it. Why all this? To arise rage, to avenge vengeance, I put its blood on a bare rock, without being covered. Seven sins did Israel commit on that day. They killed a priest, prophet, and judge, spilled innocent blood, defiled the Temple courtyard, and it was a Sabbath and Day of Atonement. When Nebuzaraddan came here and saw the blood bubbling, he asked them, what is the matter with this? They told him, it is the blood of bulls, sheep, and rams, which we were sacrificing on the altar. Immediately he brought bulls, rams, and sheep and slaughtered them on it, but the blood still was bubbling. Since they did not confess, he hung them on gallows. They said, since the Holy One, praise to Him, wants to ask for his blood from us, they told him, it is the blood of a priest, prophet, and judge who was prophesying for us [all that you are doing to us.] We conspired against him and killed him. Immediately he brought 80’000 young priests and slaughtered them on it, but the blood was still bubbling. At this moment he got angry with him, and said to him, do you want to destroy your entire people because of you? Immediately the Holy One, praise to Him, was filled with mercy and said, if this one who is flesh and blood, and cruel, is filled with mercy for My children, I, where it is written about Me, for a compassionate power is the Eternal, your God, He will not destroy you nor forget the covenant of your forefathers, not so much more? Immediately he indicated to the blood and it was absorbed on its place.


Sanhedrin 96b:5; The William Davidson Talmud (Koren - Steinsaltz) https://www.sefaria.org/Sanhedrin.96b.5?lang=bi 

When he reached the Sanctuary, he saw the blood of Zechariah the priest boiling. It had not calmed since he was killed in the Temple (see II Chronicles 24:20–22). Nebuzaradan said to the priests there: What is this? They said to him: It is the blood of offerings that was spilled. Nebuzaradan said to them: Bring animals and I will test to determine if the blood of the animals is similar to the blood that is boiling. He slaughtered the animals and their blood was not similar to the boiling blood. Nebuzaradan said to the priests: Reveal the source of that blood to me, and if not I will comb your flesh with an iron comb.


FN26:


Tuesday, April 29, 2025

Jerome - Scriptures are the Foundation, Law, and Authority

Jerome, Letter 152 (to Riparius)

Nor am I moved by their writings, which I do not know, since I know that the will indeed of blasphemy is most wicked, but that they have not the strength of prudence and eloquence — especially also [not] the knowledge of the Holy Scriptures, which are the foundation of the faith, and the law of the ecclesiastical forum, and the authority of the ancestors.

Nec eorum scriptis, quae ignoro, moueor, cum sciam uoluntatem quidem blasphemiae pessimam, sed uires prudentiae et eloquentiae non habere praecipueque sanctarum scripturarum notitiam, quae sunt fidei firmamentum et ius ecclesiastici fori auctoritasque maiorum.

Riparius was a priest to whom Jerome annually wrote, although only four of the letters survive (per Andrew Cain).

Latin from CSEL 56 (p. 365)

Monday, April 21, 2025

Libertarian Free Will and James White's Debate with AK Richardson

Did Dr. James R. White "concede" that Adam had Libertarian Free Will?  There was a moment in Dr. White's debate with AK Richardson, where AK asked whether Adam had free will.  Here is my transcript of the exchange: 

AK: Do you believe that if God purposes to design man with libertarian free will - as we call it - and then given the responsibility to believe can he do that if he wants. 

JRW: Yeah It didn't last long That was called Adam 

AK: Okay So so then if if so he did create Adam with libertarian free will So then you would concede--

JRW: But even then that libertarian free will existed under the decree of God because it was not God's purpose that Christ was not going to come The incarnation wasn't going to be ne necessary stuff like that. But Adam is completely different than we are Once the fall takes place we're in Romans 5.

AK: But you did affirm that he had libertarian free will?

JRW: Yes. As a creature. In other words he did not have a fallen nature. 

When Dr. White said "even then that libertarian free will existed under the decree of God," (link to clip) and again when Dr. White said, "in other words he did not have a fallen nature," (link to clip) it should have been apparent to the unbiased listener that Dr. White is speaking only of Adam having Freedom of Will in the sense of not being bound by a sin nature, and not of Adam having Freedom from God's Will.

So, no.  Dr. White was not saying that Adam had Libertarian Free Will in the sense that contemporary philosophers use that term (link), for example as in contrast with Compatible Free Will.  I would have preferred Dr. White to have clarified by saying "free will, not Libertarian Free Will."  However, I'm not the boss of him.  

For Dr. White, he felt it was sufficient to clarify that Adam had free will "as a creature" and more specifically as an "unfallen creature".  As he said a few seconds later:

AK: Let me ask you this way: You still you would believe then -- and you would agree -- that being libertarianly free does not in any way oppose God being sovereign? 

JRW: Libertarianly free as a creature. Adam's choices were limited. Adam could not libertarianly freely choose to fly. So he was a creature. He had that freedom within that realm as an unfallen creature.

(link to clip)

I realize that for a lot of folks, that segment of the debate was a "gotcha" moment, because of the more standard meaning of "Libertarian Free Will" in contemporary philosophical circles.  That said, it's worth observing that, to put it bluntly, that's not what Dr. White meant.

If AK had asked Dr. White the question: was the Fall foreordained by God? The answer would have been "yes," because Dr. White said that Adam's will "existed under the decree of God."

Hopefully this provides clarification for those who badly need clarification on this issue.

Saturday, April 19, 2025

Revelation 16:5 Debate - Opening Argument

The following is my planned opening argument in the Revelation 16:5 debate:

The angel of the waters said (and John heard), “hosios” (or perhaps hesed) and John wrote by inspiration of the Holy Spirit and command of Jesus Christ, “hosios.” Therefore, Beza was wrong to replace “hosios” with “esomenos,” and the King James translators ought not to have followed Beza’s reading.

Today’s debate is significant because of Revelation’s warning against adding to or diminishing from God’s word.  Today’s debate is also significant because this is one of the places where the evidence is overwhelmingly against the King James text.  In fact, unlike most textual variants, we can pinpoint the particular document that introduced this textual variant into the textual tradition: a manual markup by Theodore Beza of his own previous printed edition.  The external and internal evidence could hardly be any stronger than they are in this example.

The External Evidence

The overwhelming majority of Greek manuscripts (including the four earliest manuscripts) have hosios.  The few that do not have hosios do not substitute esomenos for hosios.  

The same is true of the translations of the Bible before the age of printing: Syriac, Armenian, Georgian, Ethiopic, Multiple Old Latin translations, Jerome’s Vulgate, and Old Church Slavonic have an equivalent of hosios. There are two branches of Coptic, one of which has the equivalent of hosios, and one which does not. Likewise, Arabic appears to have the equivalent of hosios.  On the other hand, one Middle English version does not have the equivalent of hosios, but it also does not replace it with the equivalent of esomenos.

The same is true of the commentaries on the text.  The commentaries, whether in Greek or in any other language, either reflect the presence of the word hosios or, if they do not, do not reflect esomenos as a substitute for hosios. Aside from commentaries, there are no patristic quotations of the text of Revelation 16:5 (that I could find).  

In 1505, Erasmus published Lorenzo Valla’s comments on Revelation 16:5.  As published by Erasmus in 1505, Valla seems to be suggesting that his Greek manuscript of Revelation had hagios not hosios.  As there is no such manuscript tradition, my suspicion is that Valla (or Erasmus) had notes in Latin and back translated from sanctus to the more common Greek word hagios.

That’s not to suggest that there is no textual difficulty with hosios in Revelation 16:5.  There are a cluster of variant readings (all including hosios), presumably because using the adjective hosios with an article is not standard Greek.  This bothered Beza, who called attention to this issue when arguing for his substitution of esomenos for hosios.  This, of course, leads us to the question of the internal evidence.

The Internal Evidence

Revelation 13 had introduced to us that the Beast demanded everyone’s worship and killed those who didn’t worship him.  Revelation 14 warned of the coming judgment for the beast worshippers. Revelation 15 introduces seven angels with seven bowls full of the wrath of God. Revelation 16 then provides discussion of these seven angels pouring out these bowls of God’s wrath.  

Revelation 15:2-4 

And I saw as it were a sea of glass mingled with fire: and them that had gotten the victory over the beast, and over his image, and over his mark, [and] over the number of his name, stand on the sea of glass, having the harps of God. And they sing the song of Moses the servant of God, and the song of the Lamb, saying, Great and marvellous [are] thy works, Lord God Almighty; just and true [are] thy ways, thou King of [ages]. Who shall not fear thee, O Lord, and glorify thy name? for [thou] only [art] holy: for all nations shall come and worship before thee; for thy judgments are made manifest.

The word translated “holy” in “thou only art holy” is the word hosios.  It is the only other time that John uses the word hosios, and the word is only used a few other times in the New Testament:

[Act 2:27 KJV] 27 Because thou wilt not leave my soul in hell, neither wilt thou suffer thine Holy One[G3741] to see corruption.

[Act 13:34-35 KJV] 34 And as concerning that he raised him up from the dead, [now] no more to return to corruption, he said on this wise, I will give you the sure mercies[G3741] of David. 35 Wherefore he saith also in another [psalm], Thou shalt not suffer thine Holy One[G3741] to see corruption.

[1Ti 2:8 KJV] 8 I will therefore that men pray every where, lifting up holy[G3741] hands, without wrath and doubting.

[Tit 1:8 KJV] 8 But a lover of hospitality, a lover of good men, sober, just, holy,[G3741] temperate;

[Heb 7:26 KJV] 26 For such an high priest became us, [who is] holy,[G3741] harmless, undefiled, separate from sinners, and made higher than the heavens;

It may not be immediately obvious, but hosios carries the sense of “keeping the covenant” (i.e. the same meaning as Hebrew hesed) or otherwise being “religiously correct.” That’s why the word is translated as “holy one” in Acts 2:27 and 13:35 but as “sure mercies” in Acts 13:34, both of which are quoting from the Old Testament where the Hebrew word is hesed or hasid (Psalm 16:10 “Holy One” (ḥāsîḏ) and Isaiah 55:3 “mercies” (ḥeseḏ)).  Paul and the author of Hebrews, not quoting from the Old Testament, use the word in its more general sense of religious correctness.

In context, in Revelation 15, the word hosios is connected with God’s covenant-keeping duty of bringing judgment on those who hurt his covenant people: as it is written, Vengeance is Mine, saith the Lord, I will repay.  Thus, it does not carry its more general sense of religious correctness (as in the epistles), but rather to the covenantal relationship between God and His people.

In Revelation 16, the angels pour out their bowls of wrath.  The third angel is described this way:

Revelation 16:4-7 

And the third angel poured out his vial upon the rivers and fountains of waters; and they became blood. 5 And I heard the angel of the waters say, Thou art righteous, [[O Lord,]] which art, and wast, [[and shalt be O Holy One!]], because thou hast judged thus. For they have shed the blood of saints and prophets, and thou hast given them blood to drink; for they are worthy. And I heard another out of the altar say, Even so, Lord God Almighty, true and righteous [are] thy judgments.

The voice from the altar seems to allude to the martyrs mentioned with reference the fifth seal back in Revelation 6:9-11, where the martyrs “cried with a loud voice” for God’s vengeance and were located “under the altar.” 

[Rev 6:9-11 KJV] 9 And when he had opened the fifth seal, I saw under the altar the souls of them that were slain for the word of God, and for the testimony which they held: 10 And they cried with a loud voice, saying, How long, O Lord, holy and true, dost thou not judge and avenge our blood on them that dwell on the earth? 11 And white robes were given unto every one of them; and it was said unto them, that they should rest yet for a little season, until their fellowservants also and their brethren, that should be killed as they [were], should be fulfilled.

The parallel between “true and righteous [are] thy judgments” in Revelation 16 and “just and true [are] thy ways” in the song in Chapter 15 should immediately apparent. Others have noted additional parallels.  With that in mind, hosios in Revelation 16:5, while an usual word in itself, is the correct word to make the connection back to Revelation 15.

In addition, referring to God as the one who is Hosios here makes sense because this is the fulfillment of God’s promise of judgment on those who hurt His people.

There is an additional parallel problem to be addressed.  The phrase preceding hosios is found similarly in four other passages: Revelation 1:4, 1:8, and 11:17 have the phrase, “ho on kai ho en,” and Revelation 4:8 has the phrase “ho en kai ho on.”  God as the “Being One” and “He who has been” are divine titles that, like ego eime (I AM) are connected to the tetragrammaton YHWH.  

In itself this, of course, would seem to be basically irrelevant to the wording here. What makes it more relevant is that Beza believed that in all four of those previous instances, the phrase had been followed by “ho erchomenos” (the Coming One).  It has been tempting to commentators to link the present participle and imperfect indicative of the verb “to be” together with “the coming one” to form a “past, present, future” set.  Moreover, the tetragrammaton has been taken by many as having, including, or at least being based on a future sense, “I shall be,” making some kind of reference to the future seem fitting.    

However, Beza was wrong to believe that all four previous instances were followed by the expression, “the coming one.”  Although a minority of manuscripts do have “the coming one” in Revelation 11:17, the majority of manuscripts (quite properly) do not have that title there.  The reason it is is proper not to have it there is that by Revelation 11, God has already come in judgment.  For the same reason, of course, such a title is not appropriate in the mouth of the angel in Revelation 16, because judgment has already begun to have been meted out.  

Beza recognized the impropriety of including ho erchomenos here, but still felt that it was not right to leave “the being one” and “He who has been” without a third partner, and so he substituted esomenos for hosios.  Beza’s annotations say that this is a reading that was “restored from an old reliable manuscript.”

Is it possible that such a manuscript once existed or even still exists somewhere? Many things are possible.  What is startling, however, is that no one who has collated manuscripts of Revelation (including Hoskier, who collated almost all the manuscripts that were known before World War II) has ever seen such a manuscript. On top of that, Beza is not known to have have personally possessed any Greek manuscripts of Revelation.  

Henry Stephanus collated manuscripts in that time, and seems to have provided collation notes to Theodore Beza.  However, while Stephanus’ published apparatus notes one textual variant at Revelation 16:5, this variant is not identified.  It is believed that Stephanus had additional textual variants noted in his unpublished collation notes, but that document itself seems to have been lost.

Ultimately, while it makes for an interesting historical question (whether Beza’s annotations mischaracterize the manuscript record), it’s essentially a moot point.  Even if such a manuscript existed, we would not find such a manuscript a persuasive reason to overturn all the rest of the manuscript and version tradition, nor would we find such a reading persuasive on internal grounds.

After all, the conjugation esomenos never appears in the New Testament. Septuagint Job seems to use the word once, but not as title of God.  The use of esomenos as potentially a divine title seems to have its origins in Christian adoption of Greek philosophy, particularly (in this instance) Plato’s Timaeus. Aldo Manuzio printed Plato’s collected works, first in 1513, even before Erasmus’ first edition of the Greek New Testament in 1516. We know that Beza read Plato.  Jeffrey Mallinson states: “Despite these negative sentiments, there are other instances in which Beza speaks positively of Plato.  This practice follows a Renaissance trend to harmonize Plato and Aristotle.  An important example of this harmonization is found in Jean de Serres’ … three-volume edition of the works of Plato, which contains translation and accompanying explanation of the text. … A Latin poem lauding Plato and de Serres, composed by Beza, is affixed to the first volume. Also, at de Serres’ request, Beza passed on a copy of the Platonis opera to Peter Young, tutor to Scotland’s James VI, and sent the work with a letter of recommendation.” Faith, Reason, and Revelation, Chapter 2 “Beza’s Academic Challenge” (p. 61)

I have argued for the propriety of the word "hosios" in Revelation 16:5, contending it was wrongly replaced with "esomenos" by Theodore Beza and subsequently adopted by the King James translators. The evidence presented includes the overwhelming support for "hosios" in early Greek manuscripts, ancient translations, and commentaries, contrasted with Beza's singular alteration. Internally, "hosios" connects to its usage in Revelation 15 and other New Testament verses, emphasizing God's covenant-keeping and just judgment, aligning with the context of wrath being poured out in Revelation 16. Beza's substitution is traced to a potentially non-existent manuscript and his philosophical leanings, which are deemed less credible than the weight of existing textual evidence.


Friday, April 18, 2025

5 Million Blog Views - A Sincere Thank You!

Thanks to the many visitors to this blog over the past twenty years (or so) of operation.  I noticed a remarkable surge in visitors to the blog since the start of April, and I certainly appreciate all the extra attention.  The extra visits have moved the blog up to the 5 million views level, according to the site's statistics.

I hope that the blog continues to be a blessing to folks who visit.  

To God be the glory, both now and to the ages of ages.

Manetti's Revelation 16:5

Giannozzo Manetti (1396-1459) was one of the intellectual giants of the 15th century in the field of translation.  His translation of the New Testament remains (as far as I can tell) unpublished.  However, thanks to the digital age (and thanks to James Snapp pointing my way to the manuscripts), the manuscripts are available to view online.  At Revelation 16:5, Manetti has:

et audiui angelum quartum dicentem. Justus es domine qui es et qui eras Sanctus. quiaa hec iudicaste.

(Urb.lat.6 250v)

The Greek from which Manetti was translating is known.  The Greek manuscript he used for Revelation 16:5 is this:

(Pal.gr.171 176r) aka GA 149 (15th century)
As you can see, the text here is:  ... ὁ ὢν καὶ ὁ ἦν ὁ ὅσιος ...

Evidently, Manetti also had access to and relied upon a Vulgate manuscript:

(Pal. lat. 18 389v)

It is interesting how the "fourth angel" and "Lord" crept into Manetti's "translation" of the text here.




Sunday, April 13, 2025

John Chrysostom and Jerome on Zechariah the son of Berechiah

Two theologians (contemporaries of one another and probably writing within the same decade or so) commented on Matthew 23:35 "Zacharias, the son of Barachias".  John Chrysostom, providing a homily, addresses the issue in a very summary way. 

John Chrysostom (c. 347 - 407), Homily 74 on Matthew (390-397):

But who is this Zacharias? Some say, the father of John; some, the prophet; some, a priest with two different names, whom the Scripture also calls, the son of Jehoiada.

By contrast, Jerome, writing a commentary, dives into much greater depth (footnotes are from the Fathers of the Church series)

Jerome (c. 347 - 420), Commentary on Matthew (398), Book Four, at 23:35-36 (pp. 266-68)

23.35-36. “That upon you may come all the just blood that has been shed on earth, from the blood of just Abel to the blood of Zechariah the son of Barachiah, who was murdered between the sanctuary and the altar. Amen I say to you, all these things will come upon this generation.” There is no doubt that Abel is the one killed by his brother Cain.[FN40] He is acknowledged as just not only by the Lord’s judgment, but by the testimony of Genesis, where his gifts are described as having been accepted by God.[FN41] But we do need to ask who this Zechariah son of Barachiah is. For we read about many Zechariahs. He even removes the possibility of error for us by adding: “whom you killed between the sanctuary and the altar.” I have read diverse things in diverse sources, and I ought to record the opinions of each of these. Some[FN42] say that Zechariah son of Barachiah is the eleventh of the twelve prophets. The name of his father is in agreement with this,[FN43] but the Scripture does not say when he was killed between the sanctuary and the altar, chiefly since in his time there were scarcely even ruins of the Temple. Others[FN44] want this Zechariah to be understood as the father of John.[FN45] They approve of certain daydreams from apocryphal writings that say that he was killed because he had predicted the Savior’s advent.[FN46] Since this view does not have the authority of the Scriptures, it is rejected with the same facility with which it is approved. Others[FN47] want this Zechariah to be the one who was killed between the sanctuary and the altar by Joash king of Judea, as the history of Kings narrates.[FN48] But one should observe that that Zechariah was not the son of Barachiah, but the son of Jehoiada the priest.[FN49] This is why the Scripture relates: “Joash did not remember the good deeds of Jehoiada his father, which he had done for him.”[FN50] Since, then, we should also retain Zechariah and the place of the killing is in agreement, we need to ask why he is called the son of Barachiah, and not of Jehoiada. Barachiah means “blessed of the Lord” in our language, and the justice of the priest Jehoiada is shown in the Hebrew language.[FN51] In the gospel that the Nazarenes use,[FN52] in place of “son of Barachiah” we have found it written: “son of Jehoiada.” Rather simple brothers point out reddish stones among the ruins of the sanctuary and the altar, or at the exits of the gates which lead to Siloam. They think that these were stained by the blood of Zechariah. We should not condemn their error, because it arises from their pious faith and from the malice of the Jews. We should briefly explain what he means when he says that the blood of just Abel until Zechariah son of Barachiah is required from this generation, seeing that [this generation] has put neither of them to death. The pattern of the Scriptures is to record two [kinds of] generations, [namely,] those who are good or those who are evil; that is, each generation is noted for the one or the other. Let us consider examples of the good: “Who ascends on the mountain of the Lord, or who rests on his holy mountain?”[FN53] And since he has described very many who would ascend the mountain of the Lord, who lived in various ages, afterward he adds: “This is the generation of those who seek the Lord, of those who seek the face of the God of Jacob.”[FN54] And in another passage it speaks of all the saints: “The generation of the just will be blessed.”[FN55] But of the evil it speaks as in the present passage: “A generation of vipers,” and “all things will be required of this generation.” And in Ezekiel, when he had described the sins of the land, the prophetic words added: “If Noah and Job and Daniel were found there, I would not forgive the sins of this land.”[FN56] By Noah, Job, and Daniel, he wants all the just to be understood, who are like them in their virtues. Therefore, even those who committed deeds against the apostles similar to [those of] Cain and Joash are referred to as being of a single generation.

Footnotes:

40. Cf. Gn 4.8.

41. Cf. Gn 4.5.

42. Cf. Origen, In Matth. comm. series, 25.

43. Cf. Zec 1.1.

44. Cf. Origen, In Matth. comm. series, 25.

45. Cf. Lk 1.5, 13.

46. Cf. Origen, In Matth. comm. series, 25; Epiphanius, Haer. 26.12.1-4. The apocryphal writing in question is the Genna Marias or “Birth of Mary,” also called The Protevangeliwm of James, which records that Zechariah, father of John the Baptist, was murdered by the same Herod who ordered the slaughter of the babies at Bethlehem. Probably this legend was suggested by the reference in Matthew’s text. See Hennecke-Schneemelcher, NTA 1, 344-45; ANF 8, 366.

47. Cf. Origen, In Matth comm. series, 25.

48. Cf. 2 Chr 24.22.

49. Cf. 2 Chr 24.20. H. Ridderbos, Matthew, Bible Student's Commentary (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1987), 433, thinks that the best explanation is to assume that the name of the prophet Zechariah's father was added later by an uninformed copyist.

50. 2 Chr 24.22.

51. Cf. De interpr. hebr. nom., p. 60 and p. 39.

52. See Pref., n. 6. It is interesting that immediately above this Jerome can condemn Origen (anonymously) for citing an apocryphal writing with approval, and then shortly thereafter cite one himself.

53. Ps 24.3.

54. Ps 24.6.

55. Ps 112.2.

56. Ezek 14.14.

*** 

TurretinFan's comments: 

Regarding footnote 54, it is less clear to me than to Thomas P. Scheck (the translator of the text and, I presume, author of the footnote) that Jerome is endorsing an apocryphal gospel, namely the Gospel of the Nazarenes.  Indeed, it seems that the majority of our information about this document comes from Jerome's references.

Regarding footnote 46, I agree with Scheck that Origen is likely the one in Jerome's sights for this error, and that both Origen and Tatian (who presumably influenced Epiphanius later) seem to have been influenced by the Protoevangelium of James.

Regarding footnote 49, it is interesting to note that one of the oldest copies of Matthew (codex Sinaiticus) omitted "son of Barachias" (although it was added to the margin by a corrector): 

My main reservations about this theory that the surname was added later by an uninformed copyist is that we appear to have multiple independent second-century attestation to the longer reading via Origen (c. 185 – c. 253)(Letter to Africanus), Tatian  (c. 120 – c. 180 AD)(Diatesseron), Irenaeus (c. 130 – c. 202 AD)(Against Heresies, Book 5, Chapter 14)


Monday, March 31, 2025

Jerome on Haggai 1 and Sola Scriptura

In the following, please consider how Jerome contrasts arguments from Scripture with arguments from alleged Apostolic tradition.

Jerome on Haggai, Chapter 1, vss. 11-12: 

(Verse 11.)

And I called for a drought upon the land, and upon the mountains, and upon the wheat, and upon the wine, and upon the oil, and upon whatever the ground brings forth, and upon men, and upon beasts, and upon all the labor of hands.

Concerning the drought, the Septuagint translated it as μαχαίραν (machairan), that is, a sword; but also in the Hebrew I found it written with three letters (ח ר ב), HETH, RES, BETH. If we read it as HAREB, it sounds like "sword"; if OREB, it means καύσωμα (kausōma) (or καῦμα (kauma)), which we have translated as "drought," although it might better be translated as "scorching wind."

And truly, since the discourse is about the land and the barrenness of the fields, it seems to me that in the present place a scorching wind ought to be understood rather than a sword — although any plague which is inflicted upon men because of sins can also be understood as a sword.

Therefore, the drought, or the sword, was called upon the land and upon the mountains, so that they might not produce wheat and wine and oil and whatever the ground naturally generates. After the famine comes first, consequently death comes upon men and upon beasts.

And the same sword or scorching wind consumes all that the hands of men have labored for. Therefore, the living word of God is called forth or brought forth, which is living, and effective, and sharper than any two-edged sword (Hebrews 4), so that the negligent soul (which is interpreted as dry land, and which desires rather to dwell in hollow places than to build the house of God) might be struck with its blade and whatever fruits it thinks it possesses might be destroyed.

A sword is also brought upon the mountains that lift themselves up against the knowledge of God, and upon the wheat and the wine and the oil — with which the gatherings of heretics flatter the deceived people, as though with food and drink and refreshment.

One might fittingly say that their bread is the bread of mourning, and that their wine is the fury of dragons and the incurable fury of asps. Also the oil — which is the promise concerning heavenly things, with which they anoint their disciples and promise the rewards of their labors — is detested by the prophet, who says:

"But the oil of a sinner shall not anoint my head" (Psalm 141:5).

And likewise, the other things which they discover and fabricate without the authority and testimonies of the Scriptures, as though by apostolic tradition, are struck down by the sword of God.

But let us take "men and beasts" to mean λογισμοὺς (logismous) and αἰσθήσεις (aisthēseis) — that is, their thoughts and senses — or certainly the rational and irrational in them, that is, both the learned and the unlearned alike.

And "all the labor of their hands" refers to their fastings and various observances and chameunias (chameunias) — that is, sleeping on the ground.

Those who fast during three Lents per year and humble their souls with ξηροφαγίαις (xērophagiais) — that is, eating dry foods — and who especially grow from the root of Tatian, hear concerning such labors:

"You have suffered so many things in vain" (Galatians 3:4).

But all these things that I have said can be understood concerning the rulers of the Church, who, building a carnal house and providing for their children and their possessions, do not care either to build the temple of God within themselves or to restore the Church of the Lord, which is uncovered and ruined.

The life and discordant speech of such men often scandalize many, cast them out of the Church, and lead the house of God into desolation.

But we do not say these things to accuse everyone generally, but because in every office and rank there are some who build and others who destroy the temple of God — and because of their fault, neither the dew of heaven comes down nor does the earth bring forth fruit; the ground dries up, the mountains become barren, the wheat and the oil and all that the earth produces perish, as do men themselves and beasts, and all the labor of hands is cut down and destroyed by the sword and the drought, or by the scorching wind.

(Latin can be found here)


Sunday, March 30, 2025

Archbishop Averkii, on the Woman of Revelation 12

I shouldn't have to put a disclaimer like this, but since people sometimes misunderstand the purpose of a quotation, I will simply bluntly say that I'm not posting this as an endorsement of the work.  

Averky Taushev of Syracuse, Archbishop of Jordanville, (Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia) (1906-1976), wrote a commentary on Revelation.  The following is from Chapter 12, pp. 135-6, of "The Apocalypse of St. John: an Orthodox commentary." (available here)

CHAPTER TWELVE

THE THIRD VISION: THE BATTLE OF THE KINGDOM OF GOD WITH THE POWER HOSTILE TO IT OF ANTICHRIST: THE CHURCH OF CHRIST UNDER THE IMAGE OF THE WOMAN TRAVAILING IN BIRTH

12:1-2 And there appeared a great wonder in heaven; a woman clothed with the sun, and the moon under her feet, and upon her head a crown of twelve stars: and she being with child cried, travailing in birth, and pained to be delivered.

Certain commentators have seen in this mystical woman the Most Holy Theotokos, but such outstanding commentators as St. Hippolytus, St. Methodius, and St. Andrew of Caesarea find that this is "the Church clothed in the Word of the Father, shining more brightly than the sun." This brilliance of the sun signifies likewise that she possesses the true knowledge of God and His laws and contains His revelations. The moon under her feet is a sign of the fact that she is above everything that changes. St. Methodius considers the moon allegorically as the "faith of those cleansed of corruption by the bath, that is, baptism, since upon the moon depends the nature of moisture."

On her head is a crown of twelve stars that, being originally gathered together from the twelve tribes of Israel, she subsequently was guided by the twelve apostles who comprise her light-bearing glory.

From the fact that she is in pain during childbirth, it is evident that it is incorrect to see in this woman the Most Holy Theotokos, for the giving birth from Her of the Son of God was without pain.

These torments of birthgiving signify the difficulties which had to be overcome by the Church of Christ when it was being established in the world (martyrdom, the spreading of heresies). At the same time it signifies, in the explanation of St. Andrew, that "the Church is pained for each one of those who is reborn by water and the Spirit until, as the divine Apostle has said, Christ shall be formed in them. St. Methodius says. "The Church is pained giving rebirth from natural to spiritual men and transforming them in appearance and image in the likeness of Christ" (St. Andrew, ch. 33).

Notice that Averkii is crystal clear that the woman is the Church, not Mary.

Wednesday, March 26, 2025

Calvin and Baruch

Did John Calvin think that Baruch was canonical Scripture?  This question came up during a recent episode of Dan and my podcast (link to episode).  After all, when responding to Trent (Acts of the Council of Trent with the Antidote), Calvin specifically observes that "Ecclesiasticus, the Wisdom of Solomon, Tobit, Judith, and the history of the Maccabees, were called by the Fathers not canonical but ecclesiastical books."  However, Calvin nowhere specifically identifies an issue with Trent's inclusion of Baruch.

Calvin's Commentary on 1 Corinthians, at 1 Corinthians 10:19-24:

Some, however, understand the term demons here as meaning the imaginary deities of the Gentiles, agreeably to their common way of speaking of them; for when they speak of demons they meant inferior deities, as, for example, heroes, and thus the term was taken in a good sense. Plato, in a variety of instances, employs the term to denote genii, or angels. That meaning, however, would be quite foreign to Paul’s design, for his object is to show that it is no light offense to have to do with actions that have any appearance of putting honor upon idols. Hence it suited his purpose, not to extenuate, but rather to magnify the impiety that is involved in it. How absurd, then, it would have been to select an honorable term to denote the most heinous wickedness! It is certain from the Prophet Baruch, (4:7,) that those things that are sacrificed to idols are sacrificed to devils (Deuteronomy 32:17; Psalm 96:5.) In that passage in the writings of the Prophet, the Greek translation, which was at that time in common use, has δαιμόνια — demons, and this is its common use in Scripture. How much more likely is it then, that Paul borrowed what he says from the Prophet, to express the enormity of the evil, than that, speaking after the manner of the heathen, he extenuated what he was desirous to hold up to utter execration!

On the other hand, elsewhere - indeed in his most central work, Calvin acknowledges that the author is uncertain:

Calvin's Institutes, Chapter 20, Section 8:

For it was most truly and piously written by the uncertain author (whoever he may have been) that wrote the book which is attributed to the prophet Baruch,[FN: French, “Pourtant ce qui est escrit en la prophetie qu’on attribue à Baruch, combien que l’autheur soit incertain, est tres sainctement dit;”—However, what is written in the prophecy which is attributed to Baruch, though the author is uncertain, is very holily said.] “But the soul that is greatly vexed, which goeth stooping and feeble, and the eyes that fail, and the hungry soul, will give thee praise and righteousness, O Lord. Therefore, we do not make our humble supplication before thee, O Lord our God, for the righteousness of our fathers, and of our kings.” “Hear, O Lord, and have mercy; for thou art merciful: and have pity upon us, because we have sinned before thee,” (Baruch 2:18, 19; 3:2).

The most revealing treatment of Baruch, however, comes from Calvin's take on the end of Jeremiah (Jeremiah 51:64):

The Conclusion follows, Thus far the words of Jeremiah We have said that the prophets, after having spoken in the Temple, or to the people, afterwards collected brief summaries, and that these contained the principal things: from these the prophetic books were made up. For Jeremiah did not write the volume as we have it at this day, except the chapters; and it appears evident that it was not written in the order in which he spoke. The order of time is not, then, everywhere observed; but the scribes were careful in this respect, that they collected the summaries affixed to the doors of the Temple; and so they added this conclusion, Thus far the words of Jeremiah But this, in my view, is not to be confined to the prophecies respecting the fall of Babylon; for I doubt not but that the scribe who had collected all his prophecies, added these words, that he had thus far transcribed the words of Jeremiah.

We hence conclude that the last chapter is not included in the prophetic book of Jeremiah, but that it contains history only as far as was necessary to understand what is here taught: for it appears evident that many parts of the prophecy could not be understood without the knowledge of this history. As to the book of Lamentations, we know that it was a work distinct from the prophecies of Jeremiah: there is, then, no wonder that it has been added, Thus far the words of Jeremiah

This seems to make it clear that Calvin viewed Baruch as separate from Jeremiah, since Calvin even raises some question regarding chapter 52 of Jeremiah, and did not offer any further commentary on it (much less on Baruch).  It is also extremely hard to explain why Calvin would not offer a commentary on Baruch (without explanation) if he did consider it Scripture, although Calvin did not provide a commentary on Esther, though he almost certainly considered it Scripture.

One of the commenters then suggested that according to my logic, since Calvin did not comment on Revelation, he must not have considered it to be canonical.  This is an interesting separate question (link to James Swan's interesting discussion of the question).  Ultimately, we may simply conclude that Calvin passed over 2nd and 3rd John and Revelation temporarily in order to provide Old Testament commentaries, and that his death at 55 prevented him from writing commentaries on the remainder (see the quotation from Beza in T. H. L. Parker's Calvin's New Testament Commentaries).

Finally, while we do not have a canon list directly from John Calvin himself, we have the canon list from the French Confession of Faith of 1559 (link), which includes Revelation but does not include Baruch or any of the Apocrypha highlighted by Calvin in response to Trent.  This work was based on notes from John Calvin (as discussed here)(though see this dissenting view)(and see the evolution of the Gallican Confession discussed here).

Ultimately, there ought not to be any serious doubt about Calvin's view of Baruch, considering that his commentary on Daniel ends at chapter 12 (link to volume) and considering that Calvin did not raise any known objection to the French Confession of Faith, which included Esther and Revelation, but omitted Baruch.  

Sunday, February 23, 2025

Early Versions on Revelation 16:5

Metzger's "The Early Versions of the New Testament: Their Origin, Transmission, and Limitations," provides a helpful overview of the versional evidence that can sometimes attest to a particular Greek Vorlage behind the translation.

Metzger's taxonomy provides a useful skeleton:

  1. Syriac (link to my analysis)
  2. Coptic (link to my analysis)
  3. Armenian (link to my analysis)
  4. Georgian (link to my analysis)
  5. Ethiopic (link to my very detailed analysis)
  6. "Minor Eastern" Versions
    1. Arabic  (see discussion here)
    2. Nubian (Revelation fragments exist, but not of Revelation 16:5)
    3. Persian (Only a portion of Psalms remains, apparently, from Pre-Islamic times)(see more here)
    4. Sogdian (Revelation fragments apparently don't exist)
    5. Caucasian Albanian (Revelation is not part of the extant copies)
  7. Latin
    1. Vetus Latina (link to my analysis)
    2. Vulgate (link to my analysis)
  8. Gothic (Current reconstruction of Gothic Bible does not include Revelation)
  9. Old Church Slavonic (link to my analysis)
  10. "Minor Western" Versions (None of these include Revelation, however) 
    1. Anglo-Saxon  
    2. Old High German 
    3. Old Saxon

As can be gleaned from the links above, we have already discussed the Ethiopic (Ge'ez) version at length, as also the Old Latin versions and the Vulgate in a variety of videos (mostly stemming from the usage of less literal Latin translations).  


Jerome's Vulgate at Revelation 16:5

Jerome (c.345 to 420) was one of the most influential Bible translators of history.  His translation of the Old and New Testaments (as well as the apocrypha) became the dominant Latin translation, despite the existence of several Latin translations before him.  Thus, particular attention has been paid to reconstructing the text of Jerome's translation.

The German Bible Society has published Robert Weber's recension prepared by Roger Gryson.

For reference, at Revelation 11:17 they have: "dicentes gratias agimus tibi Domine Deus omnipotens que es et qui eras quia acceptisti virtutem tuam magnam et regnasti".  They note that the Clementine Vulgate adds "et qui uenturus es"

At Revelation 15:4 they have: "quis non timebit Domine et magnificabit nomen tuum quia solus pius quoniam omnes gentes venient et adorabunt in conspectu tuo quoniam iudicia tua manifestata sunt"

At Revelation 16:5 they have: "et audivi angelum aquarum dicentem iustus es qui es et qui eras sanctus quia haec iudicasti".  They note that the Clementine Vulgate adds "domine" after "iustus es".

For comparison's sake, the New Vulgate (Nova Vulgata) has:
Revelation 11:17 
dicentes:
“ Gratias agimus tibi,
Domine, Deus omnipotens,
qui es et qui eras,
quia accepisti virtutem tuam magnam et regnasti.

Revelation 15:4

Quis non timebit, Domine,
et glorificabit nomen tuum?
Quia solus Sanctus,
quoniam omnes gentes venient
et adorabunt in conspectu tuo,
quoniam iudicia tua manifestata sunt ”.

Revelation 16:5

Et audivi angelum aquarum dicentem: “ Iustus es, qui es et qui eras, Sanctus, quia haec iudicasti;


Vetus Latina at Revelation 16:5

Roger Gryson has done incredible work in reconstructing the Old Latin versions (plural).  The versions that Gryson focuses on in Revelation have either sanctus or prius or both of those or iustes.

At Revelation 16:5, the Old Latin testimony is similarly varied but clear:
Again, hosios gets rendered as either pius or sanctus.  Where there is more variety is in the rendering of the two articular verbs ("the Being One" and "The Having-Been One").  

As Revelation 11:17 is also of interest, and because it contains the same Greek verbs, it makes sense to also note that the same kinds of variety appear at Revelation 11:17 (including, naturally, omitting the "is to come" reference in several Old Latin versions:

Syriac at Revelation 16:5

In 2014, Gorgias Press published, "The Syriac Bible with English Translation: Revelation," with the English translation by Jerome A. Lund, and the text prepared by George A. Kiraz.  The translations of 11:17 (reflecting the non-insertion of "the coming one"), 15:4 (for a comparison translation of hosios) and 16:5 are of particular interest.

At 11:17 (p. 63), Lund translates:

saying: "We thank you, O Lord God, ruler of all, who is and was, because you have assumed your great power and begun reigning.

At 15:4 (p. 83), Lund translates: 

Who should not fear you, O Lord, and glorify your name, for you alone are pure? For all the nations shall come and worship before you, for you are upright."

Similarly, at 16:5 (p. 85), Lund translates:

Then I heard the angel of the waters say: "You, he who is and was, even the pure one, are righteous, because you judged these,

I don't reproduce the Syriac text from the Gorgias Press' work here, because the text itself was published over a century ago.

The New Testament in Syriac (1905-1920)

For Revelation 16:5

(p. 187, 358/372)

Although I claim no expertise in Syriac, it appears that the text of George A. Kiraz is the same as that of the 1905 edition (perhaps with minor orthographic/font changes).

For Revelation 11:17:

(p. 183, 354/372)

Once again, the Syriac text (as expected) seems to be the same.

As p. iv of the 1905 publication and p. XIII of "The Syriac Bible with English Translation," make clear (and the Gorgias Press edition likewise reiterates), the text is based on a single Syriac manuscript.  Rev. John Gwynn, D.D., Regius Professor of Divinity at the University of Dublin transcribed the text and made various minor improvements to it (more details can be found in TSBwET - but these do not affect Revelation 11:17 or Revelation 16:5).  

Dr. Gwynn provided a presumed Greek Vorlage corresponding to the Syriac.   

(p. cxxiv, 134/318)

Revelation 11:17

(p. 23, 180/318, left column)


Revelation 16:5
(p. 31, 188/318, right column)

Revelation 4:8
(p. 9, 166/318, right column)
(p. 10, 168/318, left column)



I also looked at some older Syriac printed editions, but I'm not sure that they add anything.


Novum Testamentum Syriace denuo recognitum atque ad fidem codicum manuscriptorum emendatum (1816)

Revelation 16:5

(p. 540, 552/573)(Right column)
(p. 540, 552/573)(Left column)

(right column portion, annotated)


Revelation 11:17

(p. 534, 546/573, right column)

Reformation Era (Broadly Speaking) Bibles at Revelation 16:5

Italian (discussed here - with discussion of French)

Dutch (discussed here)

Arabic (discussed here)

Swedish

- Gustav Vasa Bible 1541 

(vol. 1, p. CLXI (verso), pdf page 761)

- Gustavus Adolphus Bible (1618)  (Could not locate - link to cover - link to many artistic aspects) According to reports, it has some updating wording and adds verse divisions, but does not change the text substantially.  

Welsh

Welsh (1588)

William Morgan (1545-1605) translated the Bible into Welsh from Hebrew and Greek (link to page).

(p. 553r, left column)

Ac mi a glywais angel y dyfroedd yn dywedyd, O Arglwydd, yr wyt yn gyfiawn, yr hwn sydd, ac yr hwn a fuost y Sanctaidd, oherwydd i ti farnu y pechau hyn.

The Welsh, "y Sanctaidd" means "the holy one."

Finnish 

Finnish (1642)

"ja Pyhä" = "and Holy"

Finnish (1685) 

(p. 302, pdf image 326)

Same as above, 1685 Finnish has "and Holy"

Romanian

New Testament of Alba Iulia (1648)

(p. 315v ("ТЄІ"), image 644/678)

For Comparison, here's the 1895 New Testament (apparently as printed in 1921):
(Sfânta Scriptura a Vechiului si Noului Testament, p. 278, image 1160/1172)

The 1895 differs in a few ways from the 1648, not the least of which is the change of alphabet.  More significant to our point, the 1895 corrects the mis-insertion of "Lord" and uses an equivalent of "Holy One" (Cuviosule), rather than what appears to be the equivalent of "and which shalt be".  

Transcription: "și carele vei fi" (lit. and which you will be)

The Cornilescu 1924 re-inserts "Lord" and uses "You are Holy": "5 Şi am auzit pe îngerul apelor zicând: „Drept eşti Tu, Doamne, care eşti şi care erai! Tu eşti Sfânt, pentru că ai judecat în felul acesta." (Compare a modern version that does not insert "Lord")

Irish 

An Biobla Naomhtha (1690)

"agus bhias" seems to be "and who shall be"

1817 edition, same text, but easier to read:

(p. 1108, image 1116/1134)

(various Irish translations here)