Bellisario Index

I have noticed that Mr. Matthew Bellisario has indicated an intent to break off further blog interaction (link). I think now is a good time to catalog comprehensively our interactions with Mr. Bellisario. Please note that the date on this blog post may eventually not be indicative of when it was actually published. Although I may let it publish initially with one date, I'm planning to date-bump it back, to keep it near other index posts. I've tried to exclude posts that merely referenced the Sola Scriptura debate without adding to it. I'll try to keep this post updated if I interact further with Mr. Bellisario. There were at least one or two other items of his in my "to-do" list.

Formal Debate

Sola Scriptura vs. Roman Catholicism Debate

1. Introduction to the Debate

2. TurretinFan's Affirmative Constructive Essay

3. Bellisario's Negative Constructive Essay

4. TurretinFan's Rebuttal Essay

5. Bellisario's Rebuttal Essay

6. TurretinFan's Question 1 (Bellisario's Answer)

7. TurretinFan's Question 2 (Bellisario's Answer)

8. TurretinFan's Question 3 (Bellisario's Answer)

9. TurretinFan's Question 4 (Bellisario's Answer)

10. TurretinFan's Question 5 (Bellisario's Answer)

11. Bellisario's Question 1 (TurretinFan's Answer)

12. Bellisario's Question 2 (TurretinFan's Answer)

13. Bellisario's Question 3 (TurretinFan's Answer)

13. Bellisario's Question 4 (TurretinFan's Answer)

14. Bellisario's Question 5 (TurretinFan's Answer)

15. Bellisario's Concluding Essay

16. TurretinFan's Concluding Essay

Informal Debates

Informal Mortal Sin of Not Observing Obligatory Holy Days Debate

TurretinFan 1 "To the Lord, I will not be Celebrating Christ's Birth" (link)

Bellisario 1 "Why Protestantism is Theologically Dead! Christ is born! Glorify Him!" (link)

TurretinFan 2 "Bellisario and Rome vs. Paul the Apostle on Christian Liberty" (link)

Bellisario 2 "Defending Christmas- Answering the Spiritually Dead! Romans 14:6 What it really means." (link)

TurretinFan 3 "Bellisario vs. His Own Imagination on Christmas" (link)

Bellisario 3 "Roman's 14 :Holy Days and Answering the Un-identifiable One. II" (link)

TurretinFan 4 "Bellisario Swings Again" (link)

Bellisario 4 "Refuting TF once again. The Fallacy of the Apostolic Age" (link)

TurretinFan 5 "Bellisario Burying Himself in the Carcases of More Straw Men" (link)

Bellisario 5 "Turetin Fan's Crippled Minded Theology on the Apostles Part I" (link)

TurretinFan 6 "Bellisario - Authority Discussion" (link)

(Index Post Specifically for this debate.)

Informal Contraception Debate

Response to Bellisario's Response to Gene Bridges on Contraception

There were multiple updates to the post above, and there were numerous comments in the com-box. I have not broken out those updates and comments individually.

Further Comments From Bellisario on Contraception and Catholicism

My Response Quoting from a Bishop of Bellisario's Church

Bellisario's Attempt to Respond

My Audio/Video Answer to Bellisario's Attempt to Respond

Bellisario's Reply to the Audio/Video Answer (A Second Reply from Bellisario)

My Response to Bellisario's Reply (Including My Response to His Second Reply as an Update)

Informal Idolatry Debate

TurretinFan 1 "The Sort of Evangelical I'm Not" (link)

Bellisario 1 "Turretin Fan vs. Saint John of Damascus" (link)

TurretinFan 2 "John of Damascus vs. Over 300 Eighth-Century Bishops" (link)

Informal Tabernacle (the Romanist Late Medieval Innovation - not the Mosaic Temporary Structure) Debate

1. September 3, 2008 - Response to Bellisario's Criticism of Dr. White

2. September 5, 2008 - Rebuttal to Bellisario's Rejoinder

Informal Eastern Orthodoxy and Transubstantiation Debate

Amalgamated Flow of Transubstation/Orthodoxy Debate

Informal How Not to Debate Roman Catholicism Debate

1. Post from Bellisario Highlighting Sexual Abuse Scandal (In Response to This Post Suggesting People Shouldn't Argue Against Catholicism based on the Sexual Abuse Scandal)

2. TurretinFan's Response Providing Ten Tips for how not to Defend Roman Catholicism

3. Bellisario's Response to the List (TurretinFan's Response: As you can see from Mr. Bellisario's responses, he still doesn't see what damage he is doing to his own side by making illogical, unsupported, and (to put it as nicely as possible) silly claims while dredging up a scandal that makes his church look bad.

Informal Bigotry Debate

1. June 15, 2009 - Bellisario Complains About Dr. White's Reference to Roman Catholic Nazis
2. June 16, 2009 - My Response to Mr. Bellisario's Complaint

Informal Dura Europos Debate

1. Comment from Bellisario Regarding Dura Europos

2. My Response

3. Bellisario's Followup

Informal Virgin of Guadeloupe Debate

1. June 28, 2009 - Original Post from Me (with updates) on the Cult of Mary in Mexico

2. June 30, 2009 - Bellisario's Criticism of the Original Post

3. July 1, 2009 - My Thanks to Bellisario and Some Thoughts on Interpreting Idols

4. (Undated or Date Unknown) - Bellisario Responds by MP3 to Issue of the Painting being an Idol

5. July 2, 2009 - My Response including a Critique of the Alleged Preservation of the Idol

Informal Perspicuity Debate (co-starring Mark Shea and David Waltz)

1. 1997 - An Original Discussion between Dr. White and Mr. Shea

2. July 15, 2009 - Post from Mark Shea including Section on Perspicuity

3. July 15, 2009 - Response from Dr. White to Mark Shea's Post

4. July 21, 2009 - More Detailed Post from Mr. Shea on Perspicuity

5. July 21, 2009 - My Response to Mr. Shea's post of July 21

6. July 23, 2009 - Mr. Bellisario's Response to my post of July 21

7. July 27, 2009 - Mr. Shea endorses Mr. Bellisario's Response

8. My Response to Mr. Bellisario's July 23 post:
Part 1 - Introduction
Part 2 - Cyril of Jerusalem
Part 3 - Justin Martyr
Part 4 - Irenaeus (1/2)
Part 5 - Tertullian
Part 6 - Athanasius (1/2)
Part 7 - Hilary of Poitiers
Part 8 - Augustine
Part 9 - Chrysostom
Part 10 - Athanasius (2/2)
Part 11 - Irenaeus (2/2)
Part 12 - Conclusion

9. Objection over Minor Detail Athanasius (1/2) Post, from David Waltz

10. My Response to the Objection

11. Waltz's Further Comments in Support of his Objection (addressed by an update of item 10)

Informal Ecclesiastical Analogy Debate

1. September 1, 2009 - Steve Hays Criticizes "Blueprint for Anarchy" Argument Using Alternate Analogies

2. September 2, 2009 - Bellisario Responds to Steve Hays

3. September 10, 2009 - My Response, Emphasizing that Christ not the Roman Pontiff is the Head of the Church

Informal Canon Debate

1. October 23, 2009 - Bellisario Attempts to Raise the Canon Argument and an Argument Allegedly from Athanasius Against Sola Scriptura

2. October 23, 2009 - I respond to Bellisario's Post - Noting that the Canon Argument Undermines Romanism and that Athanasius Supports the Reformation

3. October 26, 2009 - Bellisario Responds to one Paragraph from my post

4. October 26, 2009 - My Response to Bellisario's October 26 post

Informal Dialog

Music and Worship Issues - Informal Dialog

1. November 21, 2008 - Response to Bellisario's Musical Comparison of Rap / Gregorian Chants

2. November 27, 2008 - Response to Bellisario's Attempt to Identify "Protestant" Worthip

3. December 11, 2008 - Response and Comparison to Bellisario's Location of Illicit "Protestant" Worship

Informal Debate Followed Elsewhere

Cory Tucholski on Mary vs. Bellisario

1. September 2, 2008 - First Round

2. September 20, 2008 - Second Round

3. September 29, 2008 - Third Round

Miscellaneous Posts

1. July 31, 2008 - Observation on Romanist apologetic methods

2. October 13, 2008 - Response to Bellisario's Criticism of Dr. Svendsen

3. December 16, 2008 - Response to Bellisario's Use of Leo X

4. March 14, 2009 - Bellisario Asserts that Mr. Dyer has Refuted me (My Further Response to Mr. Dyer may be found here)

5. June 27, 2009 - Transubstantiation, Metaphor, and Common Sense

6. July 9, 2009 - Bellisario on the Papacy (by Proxy) - A Response - Part 1 and Part 2

***

This ends the index, for now. I hope that my interactions with Mr. Bellisario have served to edify the body of Christ and inform all the readers.

This seems like a good place as well to identify Mr. Bellisario. Mr. Bellisario describes himself this way: "I do not have any formal degrees in theology. I have taken some classes from Notre Dame on early church history and so forth. I do however engage in my own research and I have a library well over 1000 volumes." (source) He also calls himself a "Ukrainian Rite" member of Catholicism.

To the glory of the God properly portrayed with words not paint,

-TurretinFan